One purchase or a subscription every year. That is the whole question: pay once for a dedicated truck GPS, or pay every year for a phone app. This calculator works out the total cost of each option over 1, 3 or 5 years, with mounts plus map updates priced in.
Pick a model to fill in its November 2026 price band, then change any price to match the quote in front of you. Every answer updates as you change each field.
Your comparison
Garmin dezl: one-time cost
Phone app: subscription cost
Rand McNally: one-time cost
Over 5 years, the Rand McNally TND 750 costs least at $349.99.
5 years: Garmin dezl OTR720 $449.99, Trucker Path Gold $774.95, Rand McNally TND 750 $349.99.
The Rand McNally TND 750 costs least over 5 years. The app passes the Garmin in month 35. The app passes the Rand McNally in month 27.
The checks
| Check | Result | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest at 1 year | App | $174.99 at 1 year. |
| Cheapest at 3 years | Rand McNally | $349.99 at 3 years. |
| Cheapest at 5 years | Rand McNally | $349.99 at 5 years. |
| Break-even: app vs Garmin | Month 35 | The app passes the Garmin in month 35. Past that month the one-time purchase is cheaper. |
| Break-even: app vs Rand McNally | Month 27 | The app passes the Rand McNally in month 27. Past that month the one-time purchase is cheaper. |
| Map updates | Free | Garmin dezl includes free lifetime map updates. Rand McNally TND units include lifetime maps. The app updates with the subscription. |
The figures
| Figure | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Garmin dezl OTR720, 1 year | $449.99 | Unit $449.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Garmin dezl OTR720, 3 years | $449.99 | Unit $449.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Garmin dezl OTR720, 5 years | $449.99 | Unit $449.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Trucker Path Gold, billed yearly, 1 year | $174.99 | Mount $25.00 plus subscription $149.99 a year plus data $0.00 a year. |
| Trucker Path Gold, billed yearly, 3 years | $474.97 | Mount $25.00 plus subscription $149.99 a year plus data $0.00 a year. |
| Trucker Path Gold, billed yearly, 5 years | $774.95 | Mount $25.00 plus subscription $149.99 a year plus data $0.00 a year. |
| Rand McNally TND 750, 1 year | $349.99 | Unit $349.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Rand McNally TND 750, 3 years | $349.99 | Unit $349.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Rand McNally TND 750, 5 years | $349.99 | Unit $349.99 plus mount $0.00 plus maps $0.00 a year. |
| Monthly cost at 5 years, Garmin | $7.50 | The 5 years total divided by 60 months. |
| Monthly cost at 5 years, app | $12.92 | The 5 years total divided by 60 months. |
| Monthly cost at 5 years, Rand McNally | $5.83 | The 5 years total divided by 60 months. |
| Saving at 5 years, cheapest vs dearest | $424.96 | The gap between the cheapest option and the dearest option at 5 years. |
What to do
- Buy the Rand McNally TND 750 once if you plan to keep it 5 years: it costs least over that period.
- It saves $100.00 against the Garmin dezl OTR720. It saves $424.96 against the Trucker Path Gold.
- The app passes the Garmin in month 35. Past that month, the one-time purchase is cheaper.
- The app passes the Rand McNally in month 27. Past that month, the one-time purchase is cheaper.
- Check the current price before you buy. The bands on this page are dated November 2026.
Notes
- Garmin dezl units include free lifetime map updates, up to 4 times a year, with no subscription fee. The tool prices map updates at $0 unless you change the field.
- Rand McNally TND units ship with lifetime maps. Some owners report long gaps between map releases, so the map date matters as much as the price.
- Trucker Path navigation sits in the paid Gold or Diamond tiers. The free version covers planning and parking, not truck routing.
- A mount ships in the box with both dedicated units. The phone mount is the extra cost on the app side.
- Prices on this page are bands dated November 2026, not live prices. Change any price field to match the quote in front of you.
This calculator applies the November 2026 price bands to your numbers. Confirm the current price before you buy.
Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.
Disclaimer: This tool is provided for general information only. It is not financial advice — prices change, so check the current price before you buy.
Quick answer: Over 5 years, a Garmin dezl OTR720 at $449.99 costs less than a Trucker Path Gold subscription at $149.99 a year plus a $25 phone mount, which totals $774.95. The app starts cheaper: it costs $174.99 in year one against $449.99 for the Garmin. The app passes the Garmin in month 35. A Rand McNally TND 750 at $349.99 costs least of the three over 5 years, but owners report long gaps between its map updates. All prices here are bands dated November 2026, not live prices. Change any price in the tool to match the quote in front of you.
What does a Garmin dezl cost?
A Garmin dezl costs $349.95 to $899.99 at the November 2026 bands, depending on screen size. The 6 inch OTR620 lists at $349.99. The 7 inch OTR720 lists at $449.99. The 7 inch OTR725 adds a built-in dash cam at $599.99. The 8 inch OTR820 lists at $699.99. The 10 inch OTR1020 lists at $899.99. The previous generation OTR610 still sells at $349.95. Those are one-time prices: no subscription follows the purchase.
The OTR620, OTR720, OTR725, OTR820 plus OTR1020 form the current generation. They replaced the OTR610, OTR710, OTR810 plus OTR1010. Every current model shares the same core routing: custom routes by height, weight, length, width plus hazmat class; BirdsEye satellite imagery of loading docks plus truck entrances; community-rated parking; wind speed alerts; a CAT Scale locator; plus PrePass weigh station alerts. The price gap between models buys screen size, mounting hardware plus the dash cam, not different routing.
Street prices move below the list price. The OTR720 showed at $339.99 renewed plus $449.99 new in November 2026 listings. The OTR820 showed at $699.99 new plus $724.95 as a bundle. A renewed unit costs less, but check the warranty plus the map date before you buy one. Every dezl ships with a suction cup mount plus a vehicle power cable in the box, so the mount costs nothing extra unless you want a second mount or a powered magnetic mount.
| Model | Screen | November 2026 band | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| OTR610 (previous generation) | 6 inch | $349.95 | Still sold, same core routing |
| OTR620 | 6 inch | $349.99 | Value entry point |
| OTR720 | 7 inch | $449.99 | The sweet spot for most drivers |
| OTR725 | 7 inch | $599.99 | Built-in 1080p dash cam |
| OTR820 | 8 inch | $699.99 | Powered magnetic mount in the box |
| OTR1020 | 10 inch | $899.99 | Largest screen in the range |
Garmin backs each unit with a 1 year warranty. Map updates are free for the life of the unit, up to 4 times a year, over Wi-Fi. That matters for the comparison: the Garmin total in this calculator stays flat after the purchase unless you replace the unit.
How much does Trucker Path cost per year?
Trucker Path Gold costs $149.99 a year when billed yearly, or $14.99 a month when billed monthly, which comes to $179.88 a year. Diamond costs $29.99 a month, which comes to $359.88 a year. An older Pro plan was listed at $99.99 a year. The App Store listing from October 12, 2026 shows several Gold prices at once, from $9.99 to $19.99 a month plus $99.99 or $149.99 a year, so the price you see depends on the channel plus the offer in front of you.
The plan names matter because truck navigation sits in the paid tiers. The free version covers trip planning, parking availability, fuel prices plus weigh station status. It does not route your truck. Gold adds truck routing plus offline maps. Diamond adds unlimited stops, hours-of-service planning plus fuel optimization. The Trucker Path pricing page lists an Individual Driver plan from $29.99 a month for one or two trucks. Check what truck routing needs inside the app before you plan a trip around it, because the store listing plus the pricing page describe the plans differently.
| Plan | Billing | Cost per year | What it adds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free | None | $0 | Planning plus parking, no truck routing |
| Gold | Yearly | $149.99 | Truck routing plus offline maps |
| Gold | Monthly | $179.88 | Same as Gold yearly, paid monthly |
| Diamond | Monthly | $359.88 | Unlimited stops plus HOS planning plus fuel optimization |
| Pro (older listing) | Yearly | $99.99 | Earlier paid tier |
Monthly billing costs $29.89 more per year than yearly billing for Gold. Over 5 years that gap is $149.45, which is more than a year of Gold at the yearly price. If you plan to keep the app, yearly billing is the cheaper route. The calculator prices the plan you pick, so try both billing options to see the gap.
Diamond includes hours-of-service planning. If you run on a basic ELD or paper logs, the HOS Calculator works out your available hours without a subscription.
What does a Rand McNally TND cost?
A Rand McNally TND 550 costs $89.99 to $109.99 at current street prices in November 2026, against an average tracked price of $265.74. A TND 750 costs $228.22 at the current tracked price, against an average of $360.08 plus a high of $477.27. Renewed TND 750 units showed at $279.99. The band is wide: the same unit can list $150 apart between sellers on the same day.
The TND 550 has a 5 inch screen. The TND 750 has a 7 inch screen plus a built-in dash cam on some bundles. Both run Rand Navigation 2.0 with custom truck routing plus lifetime maps included. Rand McNally also sells tablet-style units under the RANDTAB name. No street price for the RANDTAB units was verified at build time, so this calculator prices the TND 550 plus the TND 750 only. Pick Custom price to price any other unit.
The low price comes with a warning about map updates. TND units ship with lifetime maps, but owners report long gaps between releases. One owner review from October 2026 reports no map update since March 2025 for a TND 720. Another reports update failures on a TND 750. A cheap unit with old maps can cost more than a dearer unit with current maps if it routes you under a low bridge. Check the map date on any TND before you buy, plus check that the unit still updates.
Is a Garmin dezl cheaper than Trucker Path?
Over 5 years, yes at the November 2026 bands. The worked example below uses the tool defaults: a Garmin dezl OTR720 at $449.99, Trucker Path Gold at $149.99 a year plus a $25 phone mount, plus a Rand McNally TND 750 at $349.99.
| Option | 1 year | 3 years | 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garmin dezl OTR720 | $449.99 | $449.99 | $449.99 |
| Trucker Path Gold plus phone mount | $174.99 | $474.97 | $774.95 |
| Rand McNally TND 750 | $349.99 | $349.99 | $349.99 |
In year one the app wins by $275.00. The app costs $174.99 against $449.99 for the Garmin. By year three the Garmin wins by $24.98. By year five the Garmin wins by $324.96. The app passes the Garmin in month 35. The Rand McNally TND 750 costs least at 3 plus 5 years, at $349.99 flat.
The plan changes the answer. Diamond at $29.99 a month passes the Garmin in month 15. Gold billed monthly passes it in month 29. The older Pro plan at $99.99 a year passes it in month 52, inside 5 years but only just. A driver who changes phones every year or drives part time may still pick the app: the subscription follows the phone, while a dedicated unit stays in one truck.
The deciding factor is how long you keep the device. A unit kept 5 years beats any subscription at these bands. A unit replaced every 2 years costs $1,349.97 over 5 years at the OTR720 price, which loses to Gold at $774.95. Set the device life field to match how long you really keep electronics. The Cost Per Mile Calculator puts the navigation cost into your running costs per mile.
What does the calculator include?
The calculator prices four cost lines for each option: the device or subscription, the mount, map updates plus device replacement. The phone app side also prices extra data. Every line is a field you can change.
Mounts: both dedicated units ship with a mount in the box, so the mount default is $0 for Garmin plus Rand McNally. A replacement Garmin suction mount costs $10 to $15. A truck phone mount with a long arm costs $23 to $50. The phone mount default is $25. If you already own a phone mount, set the field to $0.
Map updates: Garmin dezl units include free lifetime map updates, up to 4 times a year, so the default is $0 a year. Rand McNally TND units include lifetime maps, so the default is $0 a year there too. The fields exist for paid updates or for a unit whose free updates have ended. Set a yearly figure if your unit charges for maps.
Replacement: the device life field defaults to 5 years. Inside a 5 year window that means no replacement. Set a shorter life and the calculator adds a new unit each time the life ends. A replacement is a new unit only: the mount carries over to the next unit.
Data: the extra data field defaults to $0 a year. Most drivers already pay for a phone plan, so navigation data costs nothing extra. Set a figure if you buy a data add-on for the truck. The calculator does not price the phone itself, the phone plan, a screen protector, a power cable, or a dash cam. The OTR725 has a dash cam built in. For a separate dash cam, the Dash Cam Storage Calculator sizes the memory card. Charging a phone plus a tablet all day draws cab power. The Inverter Size Calculator for Trucks works out the inverter size for your cab loads.
Which truck GPS is best for a new driver?
No single unit wins for every driver. The right pick depends on budget, horizon plus how you drive. The calculator answers the money question. The notes below answer the rest.
Tight budget plus a short horizon: start with the app. Gold at $149.99 a year plus a $25 mount costs $174.99 in year one, against $349.99 or more for any dedicated unit. You can switch to a dedicated unit later without losing anything except the subscription months you already paid.
Owner-operator keeping one truck for years: buy a dedicated unit. The OTR720 at $449.99 pays for itself against Gold in month 35, then routes free for the rest of its life. The TND 750 at $349.99 pays for itself sooner, in month 27, if its maps stay current.
Big screen or weak eyesight: the OTR820 at $699.99 or the OTR1020 at $899.99. The 8 inch plus 10 inch screens show more map at a glance. The OTR820 ships with a powered magnetic mount plus a screw-down mount in the box.
Dash cam wanted: the OTR725 at $599.99 builds the camera into the navigator, which saves dash space plus wiring. Compare it against a separate dash cam plus a plain navigator before you decide. The New Trucker Gear Cost Estimator prices the full starter kit, from dash cam to fridge to jump starter, in one budget.
Do Garmin dezl map updates cost money?
No. Every Garmin dezl OTR navigator includes free lifetime map updates. Garmin releases updates up to 4 times a year, with no subscription fee plus no expiration date. The unit downloads them over Wi-Fi, with no computer needed. You can also update through Garmin Express on a computer.
The maps cover the United States, Canada, Mexico, Puerto Rico plus other US territories. Truck-specific data rides with the maps: bridge heights, weight limits plus truck-restricted roads. A current map matters more than a new unit: an old map can route a 13 foot 6 inch trailer under a 12 foot bridge.
Rand McNally includes lifetime maps with TND units too, but the release schedule is the difference. Garmin ships updates on a steady quarterly rhythm. Rand McNally owners report gaps of a year or more between releases. The app updates its maps with the subscription, so the map is current as long as you pay. That is the one cost advantage the subscription holds over a dedicated unit with stale maps.
Does Trucker Path work without a subscription?
Partly. The free version is a planning plus parking tool. It shows truck stops, parking availability, fuel prices plus weigh station status. It does not route your truck. Truck navigation sits in the paid Gold or Diamond tiers. Offline maps are also a paid feature, so the free version needs a signal for live data.
That split shapes the real choice. A driver who already runs a dedicated GPS can use free Trucker Path for parking plus fuel prices alongside it. A driver who wants the phone to do the routing must pay for Gold or Diamond. The calculator prices the paid tiers only, because the free version does not replace a navigator.
One caution about the Trucker Path brand: its ELD product is separate from the navigation app. Trucker Path ELD Pro shows as revoked on the FMCSA list, dated May 12, 2025. The revocation covers the ELD, not the navigation app, but it is a reminder to check any ELD before you buy. The Revoked ELD Checker runs that check. The ELD Total Cost Calculator prices an ELD the same way this page prices a GPS.
What else should you budget for truck navigation?
Navigation is one line in a cab setup. The mount plus the power cable come first: a phone on a weak mount slides off the dash on the first rough road, plus a phone navigating all day drains its battery by mid-afternoon. A long-arm truck mount plus a high-output charger cost less than one missed exit.
Power: a phone, a tablet plus a fridge share one 12 volt system. The Inverter Size Calculator for Trucks sizes the inverter for your cab loads. The Truck Fridge Power Calculator works out whether your battery survives a 10 hour break with the fridge running. The Truck Idle Cost Calculator prices the fuel burned while parked, which is the cost a good route plus a charged battery help you avoid.
The rest of the kit: correct tire pressure saves fuel plus tires, so the Semi Truck Tire Pressure Calculator sets the PSI for your load. A jump starter in the side box covers a dead battery in winter; the Jump Starter Size Checker sizes one for a diesel engine. Auxiliary lights help on dark lots, but the rules vary by state, so the LED Light Bar Legal Checker checks your state before you fit one. Good rest matters as much as good routing, so the Sleeper Mattress Size Finder matches a mattress to your truck.
Route planning plus running costs: the Trip Time Estimator works out driving time plus arrival time for any route the GPS picks. The Cost Per Mile Calculator puts fuel, maintenance plus navigation into one cost per mile. The New Trucker Gear Cost Estimator prices the whole starter kit in one budget.
How do you use the Truck GPS Cost Comparison Calculator?
Work through the fields in order. The calculator updates with every change, so you can fix an answer and watch the verdict change.
- Pick the comparison period: 1, 3 or 5 years.
- Pick a Garmin dezl model, then change its price if your quote differs.
- Pick a Trucker Path plan, then change the yearly subscription if your price differs.
- Pick a Rand McNally model, then change its price if your quote differs.
- Set the mount, map update, data plus device life fields to match your setup.
- Read the verdict, the break-even months, plus the 1, 3 plus 5 year totals.
Before you rely on a result, confirm the prices against the quote in front of you. The calculator trusts the prices you enter. A model price taken from memory instead of the listing can shift the break-even month by a year. If a plan price has changed since November 2026, type the new price into the subscription field.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Garmin dezl cheaper than Trucker Path?
Over 5 years, yes at the November 2026 bands. A Garmin dezl OTR720 at $449.99 costs $324.96 less than Trucker Path Gold at $149.99 a year plus a $25 phone mount, which totals $774.95. The app is cheaper in year one, at $174.99 against $449.99. The app passes the Garmin in month 35. A Rand McNally TND 750 at $349.99 costs least of the three over 5 years.
How much does Trucker Path cost per year?
Trucker Path Gold costs $149.99 a year when billed yearly, or $14.99 a month when billed monthly, which is $179.88 a year. Diamond costs $29.99 a month, which is $359.88 a year. An older Pro plan was listed at $99.99 a year. Prices differ by purchase channel, so confirm the price inside the app before you pay. The free version covers planning and parking, not truck routing.
Do Garmin dezl map updates cost money?
No. Every Garmin dezl OTR navigator includes free lifetime map updates over Wi-Fi, up to 4 times a year, with no subscription fee and no expiration date. The maps cover the United States, Canada, Mexico, Puerto Rico plus other US territories. You can also update through Garmin Express on a computer.
Does Trucker Path work without a subscription?
Partly. The free version covers trip planning, truck parking availability, fuel prices plus weigh station status. Truck navigation sits in the paid Gold or Diamond tiers, so the free version does not route your truck. Offline maps are also a paid feature. If you drive where the signal drops, a dedicated GPS keeps routing without a connection.
What is the break-even point between a Garmin dezl and Trucker Path?
At the November 2026 bands, Trucker Path Gold at $149.99 a year plus a $25 mount passes a $449.99 Garmin dezl OTR720 in month 35. Diamond at $29.99 a month passes it in month 15. Gold billed monthly passes it in month 29. Change any price in the tool to find the break-even point for your own quote.
Is Rand McNally cheaper than Garmin?
On the November 2026 bands, yes. A Rand McNally TND 750 at $349.99 costs $100.00 less than a Garmin dezl OTR720 at $449.99. A TND 550 at $109.99 costs far less than either. The trade-off is map updates: Rand McNally includes lifetime maps, but owners report long gaps between releases. Check the map date on any unit before you buy.
Related tools
- ELD Total Cost Calculator: Garmin dezl units pair with an ELD. Work out the full cost of an ELD the same way.
- Revoked ELD Checker: check any ELD against the FMCSA revoked list before you buy.
- HOS Calculator: Diamond adds hours-of-service planning. Work out your available hours without a subscription.
- Trip Time Estimator: plan the drive time for any route once the GPS picks it.
- Cost Per Mile Calculator: put navigation into your running costs per mile.
Sources
- Garmin dezl OTR series prices plus MSRP table (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Garmin dezl OTR720, $449.99 at B and H Photo (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Best Garmin Truck GPS, prices as of Nov 18, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Garmin dezl OTR620, free lifetime map updates plus 1 year warranty (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Truck GPS app prices, App Store listings read Oct 12, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Best truck GPS comparisons, prices reviewed Nov 11, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Best GPS app for truckers, Oct 28, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Rand McNally TND 550 price history, Nov 1, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Rand McNally TND 750 price history, Nov 11, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Rand McNally owner reviews, map update complaints Oct 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Windshield GPS holders, mount prices Oct 19, 2026 (read Nov 19, 2026)
- Budget ELD comparison, Trucker Path ELD Pro revoked May 12, 2025 (checked Oct 27, 2026)