1. The trucks
New sleeper tractors cluster between $165,000 and $220,000. Current 2026 Cascadia listings run $180,000 to $195,000.
ACT Research put the average used Class 8 retail price at $64,007 in September 2026.
New truck $190,000.00. Used truck $64,007.00. Down payment $28,500.00 is 15 percent of the new truck price.
2. The lease
Typical semi-truck lease payments run $1,800 to $3,500 a month. Full-service leases run $2,500 to $3,500.
Cash due when you sign the lease. The published comparison below uses $3,000.
Lease terms usually run 3 to 5 years. A term shorter than 5 years renews on the same terms in this comparison.
Lease: $2,400.00 a month for 60 months is $144,000.00. One 60-month term costs $144,000.00. Maintenance is included in the payment.
3. The loan
Lenders usually ask 10 to 20 percent down. The default is 15 percent of the new truck price.
The working rate for a first-time buyer is 11 percent. Strong credit earns a lower rate.
Truck loans usually run 48 to 72 months. A longer term lowers the payment and raises the total interest.
Loan on the new truck: $161,500.00 at 11 percent over 60 months is $3,511.40 a month. Loan on the used truck: $35,507.00 is $772.01 a month.
4. Maintenance and resale
O Trucking puts 5-year maintenance at about $35,000 on an owned truck, or $7,000 a year.
A used truck costs more to keep running. The published comparison puts the gap at $4,000 a year.
Maintenance: $7,000.00 a year is $35,000.00 over 5 years. The used truck adds $4,000.00 a year.
A 5-year-old sleeper usually lands between $50,000 and $90,000. The default is $55,000.
A 10-year-old truck with high miles is worth far less. The published comparison uses $20,000.
Resale after 5 years: new truck $55,000.00, used truck $20,000.00.
5. Miles
ATRI reported 85,991 miles per truck in 2025. Lease mileage caps usually run 100,000 to 120,000 a year.
85,991 miles a year is 429,955 miles over 5 years.
Your entries stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.
Disclaimer: This tool is provided for general information only. It is not professional advice — verify figures from official sources before acting on them. The comparison is an estimate for planning, not financial advice.
Quick answer: At the default figures a $190,000 new truck costs $219,184.00 over 5 years after its resale value, a $64,007 used truck costs $109,820.60 and a $2,400 a month full-service lease costs $147,000.00. Buying used is cheapest by $37,179.40 against the lease.
The lease payment is 1.26 percent of the new truck price, so it passes the 1.5% rule. Enter your own numbers above for your comparison.
Buying used instead of leasing? The Used Semi Truck Cost Comparator ranks two or three used trucks by true cost per mile.
How the comparison works
All three paths run 5 years on the same truck decision. The lease path adds the signing payment, 60 monthly payments and maintenance. The buy paths add the down payment, the loan payments and maintenance, then subtract what the truck is worth at the end.
The loan payment comes from the standard loan formula at the rate and term you enter. If the loan runs past 5 years, the balance left at month 60 comes off the resale value. If the loan ends early, the payments stop and the truck is yours sooner.
The lease term prices one term only. A 36-month lease in a 5-year comparison assumes a second lease on the same terms for the remaining 24 months. A term longer than 5 years counts its first 60 months only.
Lease cost = signing payment + 60 monthly payments + maintenance over 5 years. Buy cost = down payment + loan payments + maintenance over 5 years – resale value + loan balance left. Per-mile cost = 5-year net cost divided by miles per year times 5.
The comparison counts cash costs only. It does not count tax savings, insurance differences or mileage penalties. A purchased truck can carry a first-year tax deduction that a lease does not, so check the tax side with a CPA before you decide.
Maintenance is the same every year in this tool. A used truck usually costs more to maintain than a new one, which is why the used path carries its own extra line. Raise it if the truck has high miles or no warranty left.
The 1.5% rule, in plain English
The rule is one division. Take the monthly lease payment, divide it by the truck value and multiply by 100. A result at or below 1.5 means the deal passes.
The rule comes from car leasing, where guides such as National Vehicle Solutions state it as a quick value check. It is an informal rule of thumb, not an official standard. No trucking authority states it for trucks.
| Payment as a share of the truck value | What the rule says |
|---|---|
| Below 1 percent | Exceptional value |
| 1 percent to 1.25 percent | Very strong value |
| 1.25 percent to 1.5 percent | Good value |
| Above 1.5 percent | Examine the contract carefully |
The rule only fits leases that charge for part of the truck. A walk-away lease with a strong residual value can pass it. Finance deals and lease-purchase deals repay the whole truck, so they fail it by design.
A five-year loan repays the whole truck in 60 payments. With 15 percent down, the principal alone is 1.42 percent of the truck value each month. At 11 percent the payment lands at 1.85 percent, so the rule fails a standard finance deal outright.
Passing the rule is not the same as a good deal. Stretching a loan to 7 years passes the test on the average used truck and costs $7,276 more interest than 5 years. Judge every deal on its total cost against the truck value.
The check on this page runs on the new truck price, since leases are usually written on new trucks. The result also shows the percentage against the used truck price. A payment that looks dear on a used truck value can still be fair on a new one.
What the published numbers say
TruckDispatchExperts worked a 5-year comparison on a Freightliner Cascadia at 120,000 miles a year. The table below shows its figures. They include tax savings, which this tool does not count.
| Cost item | Full-service lease | Buy new | Buy used |
|---|---|---|---|
| Down payment | $3,000 | $30,000 | $15,000 |
| Monthly payments (60 months) | $2,400 ($144,000) | $2,800 ($168,000) | $1,600 ($96,000) |
| Maintenance (5 years) | $0 (included) | $25,000 | $45,000 |
| Residual value | $0 | -$55,000 | -$20,000 |
| Tax savings | -$12,000 | -$42,000 | -$22,000 |
| 5-year net cost | $135,000 | $126,000 | $114,000 |
The same guide puts typical lease payments at $1,800 to $2,800 a month for a full-service lease. A finance lease runs $1,200 to $2,000 a month with maintenance on you. Lease terms usually run 3 to 5 years.
O Trucking puts typical semi-truck lease payments at $1,800 to $3,500 a month. Full-service leases run $2,500 to $3,500 with maintenance included. Walk-away leases run $2,200 to $3,200.
On a $150,000 truck over 5 years, finance at 15 percent down and 11 percent costs $188,830 in cash and leaves you owning the truck. A $2,800 a month lease costs $168,000 and leaves nothing. Counted against the truck resale value, finance wins by $29,170 to $69,170.
Maintenance can move the answer. O Trucking puts 5-year maintenance at about $35,000 on an owned truck, while a lease adds $0 to $45,000 depending on whether maintenance is included. A lease that includes maintenance can close the gap.
Watch the lease fine print. Most leases cap mileage at 100,000 to 120,000 a year, with $0.10 to $0.25 a mile over the limit. Turn-in charges for wear run $2,000 to $10,000.
How to use this calculator
Five steps, about three minutes. No account and no email needed.
- Enter the truck prices: the new truck price and the used truck price.
- Enter the lease: monthly payment, cash due at signing, lease term and whether maintenance is included.
- Enter the loan: down payment, interest rate and loan term.
- Enter maintenance per year, extra maintenance for the used truck, resale values and miles per year.
- Read the comparison: 5-year net cost on each path, cost per mile, the cheapest path and the 1.5% rule check.
Lease vs buy questions
Is it better to lease or buy a semi truck?
Buying usually wins on total cost, because each payment builds equity in a truck you keep. At the default figures buying used costs $109,820.60 over 5 years against $147,000.00 for a full-service lease.
Leasing suits a short-term truck or a driver short of capital. Run your own figures before you sign, since the answer turns on the price, the rate and the resale value.
What is the 1.5% rule in leasing?
The monthly lease payment should stay at or below 1.5 percent of the truck value. Divide the payment by the value and multiply by 100: a result of 1.5 or less passes.
It is a rule of thumb from car leasing, not an official standard. No trucking authority states it for trucks.
Why does a real truck payment break the 1.5% rule?
A five-year loan repays the whole truck in 60 payments. With 15 percent down, the principal alone is 1.42 percent of the truck value each month, leaving almost no room for interest.
At 11 percent the payment lands at 1.85 percent. The rule fits walk-away leases, which charge for part of the truck, not finance deals.
What monthly lease payment passes the 1.5% rule on a $190,000 truck?
$2,850 a month or less. That is 1.5 percent of $190,000.
The default lease payment of $2,400 a month is 1.26 percent, so it passes with room to spare. Only a walk-away lease with a strong residual value is likely to pass on a new truck.
Does this calculator count tax savings?
No. The comparison counts cash costs only: payments, down payment, maintenance and resale value. A purchased truck can carry a first-year tax deduction that a lease does not. Check the tax side with a CPA before you decide, since the deduction can move the answer.
What does a 5-year lease really cost?
Take the monthly payment times 60 and add the signing payment and any maintenance the lease does not include. At $2,400 a month with $3,000 due at signing and maintenance included, the 5-year cost is $147,000.00.
A lease that leaves maintenance to you adds about $35,000 over 5 years. Mileage overage and turn-in charges can add more.
Related tools and guides
- Truck Financing Calculator: price the loan side from your own truck price, deposit and rate
- Cost Per Mile Calculator: turn your payment into a per-mile figure and find your break-even rate
- Cost Stack Calculator: work out what the first year of a new authority really costs
- Per-Mile Profit Calculator: judge a single load: profit per mile after fuel, driver pay and fees
- Maintenance Reserve Calculator: work out your maintenance reserve per mile by truck age
- All Trucking Mind tools: free calculators and checkers for drivers and carriers
This calculator follows the TruckDispatchExperts 5-year comparison, the O Trucking lease guide, the National Vehicle Solutions 1.5% rule guide and the ATRI 2026 Update figures named in the source register. It is guidance, not a recommendation to lease or buy.
Each path is an estimate for planning, not a filing figure. Confirm any figure against the source before you act on it.
Your entries stay in your browser. Nothing is sent to our servers.