FMCSA assigns the rating, not this tool. This predictor applies the published Appendix B methodology to the findings you enter, then shows the rating the table produces. It is an estimate from the regulation, not the agency determination. A safety investigator may weigh factors the table does not capture.
Enter the acute violations and critical patterns from your compliance review findings, plus the inspection and accident figures. Every answer updates the result as you change each field. Leave a count at zero when the review found nothing in that factor.
About the carrier
The carrier type sets the Unsatisfactory clock: 60 days to final for property, 45 days for passenger or placarded hazmat. The urban answer sets the accident factor threshold. A carrier that hauls no hazmat is not scored on Factor 5.
Factor 1: General, Parts 387 and 390
Insurance coverage plus accident recordkeeping. Acute examples: operating without the required financial responsibility coverage, section 387.7(a). Critical examples: failing to keep proof of coverage at the principal place of business, failing to keep copies of accident reports.
Factor 2: Driver, Parts 382, 383 and 391
Drug and alcohol program, licensing, plus driver qualification. Acute examples: no testing program, using a driver known to have tested positive, using a disqualified driver. Critical examples: missing driver qualification files, missing medical certificates.
Factor 3: Operational, Parts 392 and 395
Driving rules plus hours of service. Each Part 395 critical pattern scores 2 points, not 1. Acute examples: requiring a driver to drive while impaired, ELD tampering. Critical examples: 11 hour and 14 hour violations, missing records of duty status.
Factor 4: Vehicle, Parts 393 and 396
With 3 or more vehicle inspections on file, this factor starts from the out-of-service rate: 34 percent or higher starts it at Conditional. With fewer than 3 inspections, it is scored on points like the other factors. Acute examples: operating a vehicle declared out of service, failing to correct out-of-service defects. Critical examples: missing inspection and maintenance records, using a vehicle not periodically inspected.
Factor 5: Hazardous Materials, Parts 397, 171, 177 and 180
Only scored when the carrier hauls hazardous materials. Acute examples: transporting hazmat without a security plan, accepting a forbidden material. Critical examples: missing shipping papers, unreported hazmat incidents.
Factor 6: Accident, recordable accident rate
Rated only with 2 or more recordable accidents in the past 12 months. The threshold is a rate greater than 1.5 per million miles, or greater than 1.7 for an urban carrier. Enter the miles driven in the same 12 months.
Predicted rating: Conditional.
1 factor rated Unsatisfactory and 1 factor rated Conditional.
The Appendix B rating table gives Conditional when 1 factor is Unsatisfactory and no more than 2 factors are Conditional. The carrier may keep operating, but FMCSA lists the deficiencies on the review and expects corrective action. A Conditional rating also affects shipper and broker decisions, plus insurance.
The factors
| Factor | Rating | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Factor 1 General (Parts 387 and 390) | Satisfactory | 0 acute violations plus 0 critical patterns = 0 points. |
| Factor 2 Driver (Parts 382, 383 and 391) | Conditional | 1 acute violation plus 0 critical patterns = 1 point. |
| Factor 3 Operational (Parts 392 and 395) | Unsatisfactory | 0 acute violations plus 0 Part 392 critical patterns plus 1 Part 395 critical pattern at 2 points each = 2 points. |
| Factor 4 Vehicle (Parts 393 and 396) | Satisfactory | 8 inspections with 1 out of service = 12.5% out of service. 0 acute violations plus 0 critical patterns in the Part 396 examination. |
| Factor 5 Hazardous Materials (Parts 397, 171, 177 and 180) | Satisfactory | Not evaluated: the carrier does not transport hazardous materials, so this factor does not count against the rating. |
| Factor 6 Accident (recordable accident rate) | Satisfactory | Not rated: fewer than 2 recordable accidents in the past 12 months, so the accident factor does not count against the rating. |
The figures
| Figure | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Unsatisfactory factors | 1 | 2 or more Unsatisfactory factors mean an Unsatisfactory rating on their own. |
| Conditional factors | 1 | More than 2 Conditional factors mean a Conditional rating with no Unsatisfactory factor, or an Unsatisfactory rating with 1 Unsatisfactory factor. |
| Vehicle out-of-service rate | 12.5% | 34 percent or higher starts the vehicle factor at Conditional when 3 or more inspections are on file. |
| Next step after a Conditional rating | Corrective action, then a rating-change request | Section 385.17: request a change at any time with evidence of corrective action. FMCSA reviews Unsatisfactory ratings within 30 or 45 days. No review deadline applies to a Conditional rating. |
What to do
- Factor 2 Driver: fix the driver qualification, licensing, medical and drug testing findings, then document the corrected controls.
- Factor 3 Operational: fix the hours-of-service and driving findings, then show the dispatch and log controls that prevent a repeat.
- Fix every deficiency listed on the review, then request a rating change under section 385.17 with written evidence of the corrective actions.
- Expect a follow-up review. FMCSA re-examines carriers rated Conditional to confirm the fixes hold.
What would move the rating
- Clear Factor 2 Driver alone: the rating would become Conditional.
- Clear Factor 3 Operational alone: the rating would become Satisfactory.
- Fastest path to Satisfactory: clear Factor 3 Operational.
Notes
- This tool applies the published Appendix B methodology to the findings you enter. FMCSA assigns the actual rating after a compliance review. The safety investigator may weigh factors the table does not capture.
- A pattern of noncompliance with a critical regulation means more than one violation. When documents are reviewed, the pattern line is at least 10 percent of those examined.
- A safety rating is not a CSA score. The rating comes from a compliance review under Part 385. CSA percentiles come from roadside inspections and crashes under the Safety Measurement System. A carrier can hold a Satisfactory rating while its CSA percentiles sit above the intervention thresholds.
- With 3 or more vehicle inspections on file, the vehicle factor starts from the out-of-service rate, not from points. A rate of 34 percent or higher starts the factor at Conditional.
- The 2026 inflation-adjusted penalty for operating after an Unsatisfactory rating is set in Part 386 Appendix B. Check the current appendix before quoting a figure.
This tool applies 49 CFR Part 385 Appendix B to your inputs. Confirm the result against the compliance review report plus your safety records before acting. FMCSA assigns the actual rating.
Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.
Disclaimer: This tool is a planning estimate based on the published Appendix B methodology, not legal advice — confirm the rating plus the deadlines with FMCSA or your legal counsel before acting on a compliance review result.
Quick answer: An FMCSA safety rating is Satisfactory, Conditional, or Unsatisfactory. Each one comes from a compliance review scored under 49 CFR Part 385 Appendix B. Each acute violation and each pattern of critical violations adds points to one of six safety fitness factors. A factor scores Satisfactory at zero points, Conditional at 1 point, plus Unsatisfactory at 2 or more points. The six factor ratings then feed a rating table: 2 or more Unsatisfactory factors mean an Unsatisfactory rating. 1 Unsatisfactory factor with more than 2 Conditional factors means the same. This predictor runs the same table on your findings and shows what would move the rating.
What is an FMCSA safety rating?
An FMCSA safety rating is the federal judgment of whether a motor carrier is fit to operate. FMCSA assigns one of three ratings after a compliance review: Satisfactory, Conditional, or Unsatisfactory. A Satisfactory rating means the carrier meets the safety fitness standard in 49 CFR 385.5, with adequate safety management controls in place that function effectively. A Conditional rating means the carrier does not have adequate safety management controls in place, but FMCSA has not found the carrier unfit. An Unsatisfactory rating means FMCSA has found the carrier unfit. The operating prohibition in section 385.13 follows once the rating becomes final.
The rating comes from a compliance review, not from roadside inspections alone. A safety investigator visits the carrier, examines driver qualification files, records of duty status, vehicle maintenance records, drug and alcohol program records, plus accident records, then cites violations on the review document. The investigator scores those findings under the safety fitness rating methodology in Appendix B to Part 385. The proposed rating appears on the review. FMCSA headquarters then issues the official rating in writing, no later than 30 days after the review, under section 385.11(a).
Most carriers on the road have no rating at all. A carrier that has never had a compliance review is unrated, which is neither good nor bad: it simply means FMCSA has not yet examined the carrier in depth. Shippers, brokers, plus insurers treat an unrated carrier differently from a rated one. A Conditional rating can cost a carrier freight even though the carrier may legally keep operating. A Satisfactory rating is the strongest signal a carrier can send to the market. It is the rating every safety program aims at.
The rating is public. Anyone can look up a carrier current rating on the FMCSA SAFER website or by calling (800) 832-5660. That publicity is part of the point. A rating follows the carrier in every shipper vetting check, every broker onboarding form, plus every insurance renewal. The predictor above lets a carrier see the rating its own findings would produce, before an investigator does the same arithmetic on the review document.
How is a safety rating calculated?
The calculation runs in three steps, all set out in Appendix B to Part 385. First, the investigator scores the findings by factor. Second, each factor gets a rating from its points. Third, the six factor ratings feed a rating table that produces the overall rating. The whole method is mechanical once the findings are counted, which is why a predictor can reproduce it exactly.
Step one is the point count. Appendix B section II(g) gives one point for each instance of noncompliance with an acute regulation, plus one point for each pattern of noncompliance with a critical regulation. Section II(h) makes one exception: each pattern of noncompliance with a critical regulation relative to Part 395, the hours of service rules, is assessed two points. That doubling is the single most important scoring detail in the methodology. One hours-of-service pattern is enough, on its own, to push a factor to Unsatisfactory.
Step two is the factor rating. Appendix B section II.C sets three bands: Satisfactory at zero points, Conditional at 1 point, Unsatisfactory at 2 or more points. The bands are the same for every regulatory factor. Two factors work differently: the vehicle factor starts from the out-of-service rate when enough inspections are on file. The accident factor is a rate test with no Conditional band at all. Both are covered in their own sections below.
Step three is the rating table in Appendix B section III.A. The table reads as follows.
| Unsatisfactory factors | Conditional factors | Overall rating |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 2 or fewer | Satisfactory |
| 0 | More than 2 | Conditional |
| 1 | 2 or fewer | Conditional |
| 1 | More than 2 | Unsatisfactory |
| 2 or more | Any number | Unsatisfactory |
Two features of the table surprise carriers. The first is that 3 Conditional factors, with no Unsatisfactory factor, produce only a Conditional rating, not an Unsatisfactory one. The second is that a single Unsatisfactory factor becomes an Unsatisfactory rating the moment a third Conditional factor joins it. The table rewards a carrier that keeps its problems in one factor, while it punishes a carrier whose problems spread across the operation. That is deliberate: widespread low-level noncompliance is the signature of failed management controls, which is what the safety fitness standard tests.
The predictor above runs this exact table. Enter the findings per factor. It shows each factor rating, the counts that drive the table, plus the fastest path to a better rating: which factors to clear, in the smallest combination that moves the result.
What are acute and critical violations?
Appendix B divides the regulations it scores into two classes. Acute regulations are those where noncompliance is so severe as to require immediate corrective action, regardless of the overall safety posture of the carrier. A single acute violation scores a point. Critical regulations are those where noncompliance relates to management or operational controls. Such noncompliance indicates a breakdown in those controls. A critical violation scores a point only as part of a pattern.
The pattern rule matters more than the list. Appendix B section II(g) defines a pattern as more than one violation. When a number of documents are reviewed, the number of violations required to meet a pattern is equal to at least 10 percent of those examined. One missing medical certificate in a file of 40 drivers is a violation, not a pattern. Five missing certificates in the same 40 files cross the 10 percent line and score a point. A carrier preparing for a review should count its own files against that 10 percent line before the investigator does.
The full list of acute and critical regulations sits in Appendix B section VII. The table below shows the ones investigators cite most often, grouped by factor. It is a selection, not the full list: the appendix lists more than 100 regulations. The investigator scores any of them.
| Regulation | What it covers | Class |
|---|---|---|
| 382.115(a) | Failing to implement a drug and alcohol testing program | Acute |
| 382.201 | Using a driver known to have an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater | Acute |
| 382.305(a) | Failing to implement a random testing program | Acute |
| 382.301(a) | Using a driver before receiving a negative pre-employment drug test result | Critical |
| 383.37(a) | Allowing a driver to operate without a current CDL, proper class, or endorsements | Acute |
| 383.51(a) | Knowingly allowing a disqualified driver to drive | Acute |
| 387.7(a) | Operating without the required financial responsibility coverage | Acute |
| 390.35 | Making fraudulent or intentionally false statements or records | Acute |
| 391.11(b)(4) | Using a physically unqualified driver | Acute |
| 391.51(a) | Failing to maintain a driver qualification file on each driver | Critical |
| 392.4(b) | Requiring a driver to drive while under the influence of a narcotic drug or amphetamine | Acute |
| 395.3(a)(3)(i) | Requiring a driver to drive more than 11 hours | Critical, 2 points |
| 395.8(e)(2) | Tampering with an ELD or blocking its signal | Acute |
| 396.9(c)(2) | Operating a vehicle declared out of service before repairs were made | Acute |
| 396.17(a) | Using a commercial motor vehicle not periodically inspected | Critical |
| 172.800(b) | Transporting hazardous materials without a security plan | Acute |
| 177.817(a) | Transporting hazmat without a properly prepared shipping paper | Critical |
Three entries in that table deserve a second look. Section 382.305(a), failing to implement a random testing program at all, is acute, while section 382.305(b), failing to test at the required annual rate, is critical. The difference is the difference between having no program and running a thin one. Section 395.8(e)(2), ELD tampering, is acute, while the ordinary log violations in section 395.8 are critical at 2 points a pattern. And section 390.35, fraud, is acute and can support a criminal referral on top of the rating damage. A carrier that finds an acute violation in its own audit should treat it as the top fix, because one acute violation is one point and one point is a Conditional factor.
One common misunderstanding needs correcting. Older summaries of the methodology, plus some training material still in circulation, claim that acute violations in Part 382 score 3 points. The current Appendix B text contains no 3 point scoring anywhere. Every acute instance scores 1 point. The only doubled score in the current text is the Part 395 critical pattern at 2 points. This predictor follows the current text, read from eCFR on November 19, 2026.
What are the six safety fitness factors?
Appendix B groups the regulations into five regulatory factors, plus a sixth factor for accident history. The grouping follows the safety fitness standard in section 385.5, which lists the risks a carrier must control: licensing, financial responsibility, unqualified drivers, improper driving, unsafe vehicles, accident recordkeeping, fatigued drivers, vehicle maintenance, hazmat transport, hazmat rule violations, plus accidents and hazmat incidents.
| Factor | Parts covered | What it tests |
|---|---|---|
| Factor 1, General | Parts 387 and 390 | Insurance coverage, accident registers, plus general compliance |
| Factor 2, Driver | Parts 382, 383 and 391 | Drug and alcohol program, CDL licensing, plus driver qualification |
| Factor 3, Operational | Parts 392 and 395 | Driving rules plus hours of service |
| Factor 4, Vehicle | Parts 393 and 396 | Equipment standards plus inspection, repair, plus maintenance |
| Factor 5, Hazardous Materials | Parts 397, 171, 177 and 180 | Hazmat driving and parking rules, incident reporting, shipping papers, plus cargo tanks |
| Factor 6, Accident | Recordable accident rate | Crash history per million miles over the past 12 months |
Factor 1 is the smallest in scope and the easiest to keep clean. It covers the insurance filings under Part 387 and the general requirements of Part 390, including the accident register and the accident report copies. A carrier fails Factor 1 by letting coverage lapse, by failing to keep proof of coverage at the principal place of business, or by keeping a sloppy accident register. The DOT Record Retention Checker works out how long each record in the file must be kept, including the 3 year accident register retention under section 390.15.
Factor 2 is where most carriers pick up their first point. It covers the drug and alcohol program under Part 382, the CDL rules under Part 383, plus the driver qualification rules under Part 391. The acute violations cluster here: no testing program, using a driver known to have tested positive, using a disqualified driver, using a physically unqualified driver. The critical patterns cluster here too: missing qualification files, missing medical certificates, missing inquiries into driving records. A carrier with one acute violation in Factor 2 and nothing else is already Conditional in that factor. One more point anywhere in the factor makes it Unsatisfactory.
Factor 3 carries the doubled Part 395 scoring, which makes it the most dangerous factor per finding. A single pattern of 11 hour violations scores 2 points and makes the factor Unsatisfactory on its own. Factor 4 is the only factor scored from roadside data as well as review findings, covered in the next section. Factor 5 applies only to carriers that transport hazardous materials; a carrier that hauls no hazmat is not scored on it at all. The predictor leaves it out of the table in that case. Factor 6 is a pure rate test, covered two sections below.
The factor structure is also the fix structure. Corrective action after a review is organized by factor. A rating-change request under section 385.17 must show evidence for each deficient factor. A carrier that knows which factors are deficient knows exactly what to fix first, which is why the predictor shows the factor table before anything else.
How does the vehicle factor work?
Factor 4 is the only factor that uses roadside inspection data. Appendix B section II.A sets a threshold: when 3 or more vehicle inspections are recorded in MCMIS during the 12 months prior to the review, or performed at the time of the review, or a combination of the two totaling 3 or more, the vehicle factor is evaluated on the out-of-service rate plus the Part 396 examination. Below 3 inspections, the factor is scored on points like the other regulatory factors.
With 3 or more inspections, the out-of-service rate sets the starting rating. A vehicle out-of-service rate of 34 percent or higher starts the factor at Conditional. A rate below 34 percent starts it at Satisfactory. The Part 396 examination then moves the factor one step down if the investigator finds noncompliance with an acute regulation or a pattern of noncompliance with a critical regulation: a Conditional start becomes Unsatisfactory, while a Satisfactory start becomes Conditional. If the Part 396 examination finds no such problems, the factor stays where the rate put it.
That structure produces results that surprise carriers in both directions. A carrier with a 40 percent out-of-service rate and a clean Part 396 examination is Conditional in Factor 4, not Unsatisfactory, because the rate alone cannot push the factor past Conditional. A carrier with a 10 percent out-of-service rate and one acute Part 396 violation is also Conditional, because the finding lowers the Satisfactory start one step. Only the combination of a high rate plus a Part 396 finding produces an Unsatisfactory vehicle factor.
The 34 percent line is high by design. Appendix B notes that roadside inspections are targeted at visibly defective vehicles, so the out-of-service rate overstates the true defect rate in a fleet. FMCSA set the line where it did to avoid rating a carrier on a handful of targeted inspections. Even so, a small carrier with 3 inspections and 1 out of service sits at 33 percent, one inspection away from the line. The DVIR Checker helps keep the daily inspection reports clean, which is the first line of defense against the roadside findings that feed this rate.
Carriers with fewer than 3 inspections should not relax. The points rule below the threshold is harsher in one way: a single acute Part 396 violation, such as operating a vehicle declared out of service, scores a point and makes the factor Conditional. A second point makes it Unsatisfactory, with no rate test to soften the result. The predictor switches between the two rules automatically from the inspection count you enter.
How does the accident factor work?
Factor 6 is the only factor that does not score violations at all. It scores the recordable accident rate for the past 12 months: the number of recordable accidents, divided by the miles driven in the same period, multiplied by one million. A recordable accident, under the definition in section 390.5, is an occurrence involving a commercial motor vehicle on a highway in commerce that results in a fatality, in bodily injury to a person who immediately receives medical treatment away from the scene, or in one or more vehicles incurring disabling damage that requires a tow.
The factor has a gate before the rate matters. Appendix B section II.B says the recordable accident rate will be used only when a motor carrier incurs 2 or more recordable accidents within the 12 months prior to the review. A carrier with zero or one recordable accident is not rated on Factor 6 at all. The factor simply does not count against the rating. That gate protects small carriers, where a single crash can otherwise dominate a small mileage base.
Past the gate, the test is a single threshold with two values. An urban carrier, defined as a carrier operating entirely within a radius of 100 air miles, with a recordable accident rate greater than 1.7 receives an Unsatisfactory factor rating. All other carriers with a rate greater than 1.5 receive an Unsatisfactory factor rating. There is no Conditional band for the accident factor: the rate is either at or below the line, which means Satisfactory, or above it, which means Unsatisfactory. A rate exactly at the line is Satisfactory, because the appendix says greater than, not greater than or equal to.
The thresholds come from national data. FMCSA computed recordable accidents per million miles for every compliance review performed in fiscal years 1994, 1995, plus 1996. The national average for all carriers rated was 0.747, with 0.839 for carriers operating entirely within the 100 air mile radius. The thresholds of 1.5 and 1.7 are roughly double those averages. FMCSA reasoned that urban carriers face higher exposure because of their environment, which is why their line sits higher. The figures are old, but they remain the thresholds in the current appendix text.
Preventability still matters at the margin. Appendix B section II.B says FMCSA will continue to consider preventability when a carrier contests a rating by presenting compelling evidence that the recordable rate is not a fair means of evaluating its accident factor. The standard is whether a driver who exercises normal judgment and foresight could have foreseen the possibility of the accident that in fact occurred, then avoided it by taking steps within the driver control which would not have risked causing another kind of mishap. A carrier whose rate is driven by crashes another driver caused should gather that evidence before the review, not after. The Crash Preventability Checker works out whether a crash qualifies for a Not Preventable determination under the FMCSA Crash Preventability Determination Program.
Worked example: a carrier with 3 recordable accidents and 1,000,000 miles in the past 12 months has a rate of 3.00 per million miles, which is above 1.5 and makes Factor 6 Unsatisfactory. The same 3 accidents over 2,000,000 miles give a rate of 1.50, exactly at the line, which is Satisfactory. Mileage is half the equation. A carrier that grows its miles without growing its crashes improves the factor even if the crash count stays flat.
What does each safety rating mean?
Satisfactory means the carrier meets the safety fitness standard. The rating is final on the date of the notice, under section 385.11(b). The carrier keeps operating with no restrictions. A Satisfactory rating is also a commercial asset: shippers and brokers check it, insurers price on it. A carrier that holds it can bid freight that a Conditional carrier cannot. The practical advice for a Satisfactory carrier is to protect the result. The factors that produced it need the same controls that built them, because the next review starts from zero again.
Conditional means the carrier does not have adequate safety management controls in place. The rating is proposed, not final. The carrier may keep operating while it fixes the deficiencies. FMCSA lists the deficiencies on the review. The carrier should treat that list as a work order. A Conditional rating carries no operating prohibition, but it carries commercial damage: many shippers refuse Conditional carriers outright. Insurers raise premiums or decline to renew. A Conditional carrier can request a rating change under section 385.17 at any time, once corrective actions are complete, with written evidence for each deficiency. FMCSA reviews Unsatisfactory ratings within 30 or 45 days, but no review deadline applies to a Conditional rating, so the carrier should file a complete request and follow up.
Unsatisfactory means FMCSA has found the carrier unfit. The clock in sections 385.11 and 385.13 starts running. The proposed rating becomes final 45 days after the notice for a carrier transporting passengers or hazardous materials in quantities requiring placarding, plus 60 days after the notice for all other carriers. The operating prohibition starts the day after: day 46 for the passenger and placarded hazmat group, day 61 for everyone else. Once the rating is final, FMCSA issues an out-of-service order covering the carrier operations in interstate commerce plus operations affecting interstate commerce. FMCSA then moves to revoke operating authority after notice.
Two relief routes exist inside that window. First, a carrier that believes FMCSA made a factual or procedural error can request an administrative review under section 385.15. The request goes in writing to the Assistant Administrator, ATTN: Adjudications Counsel. File within 15 days of the notice so FMCSA can decide before the prohibition starts. The outer limit is 90 days. FMCSA decides within 30 days for passenger or hazmat carriers, 45 days for others. Second, a carrier that has fixed the deficiencies can request a rating change under section 385.17 at any time, with written evidence of the corrective actions. Filing a rating-change request does not stay the 45 day period for passenger or placarded hazmat carriers. For other carriers, FMCSA may allow up to 60 additional days of operation beyond the 60 days if the carrier is making a good-faith effort to improve, with the additional period starting on day 61.
The penalty for operating after the prohibition is severe. A carrier that operates in violation of section 385.13 faces the penalty provisions of 49 U.S.C. 521(b) plus Appendix B to Part 386. A carrier that operates after revocation of operating authority faces the penalties in 49 U.S.C. 14901. Federal agencies must not use an Unsatisfactory carrier for any CMV transportation. The FMCSA Fine Calculator works out the current inflation-adjusted penalty for a given violation. The Safety Rating Explainer covers the full countdown from a proposed Unsatisfactory notice, with every deadline dated from the notice. The MC Reinstatement Checker covers the path back after a revocation.
How is a safety rating different from a CSA score?
Carriers confuse the safety rating with the CSA score more than any other pair of FMCSA systems. They measure different things, from different data, on different clocks. A carrier can hold a Satisfactory rating while its CSA percentiles sit above the intervention thresholds, or the reverse.
The safety rating comes from a compliance review. An investigator examines the carrier records in depth, scores acute and critical violations under Appendix B. It then assigns Satisfactory, Conditional, or Unsatisfactory. The rating changes only when a new review happens. It is a point-in-time judgment of management controls. It stays in place until the next review replaces it.
The CSA score, formally the Safety Measurement System, comes from roadside inspections plus crash data, updated monthly. It sorts violations into seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories, known as BASICs. The system assigns each carrier a percentile within its peer group. A high percentile means the carrier performs worse than most peers in that category. The percentiles drive FMCSA interventions: warning letters, targeted roadside inspections, plus investigations. A carrier with a clean review history can still draw a CSA investigation if its roadside data deteriorates. That investigation can lead to a compliance review that changes the rating.
The practical difference is who acts first. CSA percentiles move every month with every inspection and every crash. The rating moves only at a review. A carrier watching its CSA percentiles can see trouble coming months before a review. A carrier watching only its rating finds out at the review itself. The SMS BASIC Measure Estimator works out the CSA measure for a BASIC from inspection and violation data. The DataQs Challenge Helper covers correcting inspection and crash records that feed the SMS percentiles.
One more distinction matters for the accident factor. The Factor 6 rate in this predictor uses all recordable accidents in the past 12 months, regardless of preventability, unless the carrier contests the factor with compelling evidence. The CSA Crash Indicator BASIC uses a different crash set, with severity weights and time weights. It excludes crashes FMCSA determines Not Preventable under the Crash Preventability Determination Program. The two crash measures can point in different directions for the same carrier. The predictor uses the Appendix B measure, because that is the one the rating turns on.
How do you use the Safety Rating Predictor?
Work through the fields in order. The tool updates with every change, so you can fix an answer and watch the verdict change.
- Pick the carrier type, the urban answer, plus whether the carrier hauls hazardous materials.
- Enter the acute violations plus the critical patterns for Factors 1, 2, 3, plus 5.
- Enter the vehicle inspections, the out-of-service inspections, plus the Part 396 findings for Factor 4.
- Enter the recordable accidents plus the miles driven for Factor 6.
- Read the predicted rating, the factor table, plus the figures.
- Copy the summary and the fastest path to a better rating for the safety file.
Use the counts from a real document where possible. The best input is the violation list from the most recent compliance review, or from an internal audit scored against the Appendix B list. Counting from memory produces a guess. The predictor is only as good as the counts entered. When a count is uncertain, run the tool twice: once with the low count, once with the high count. Read the range of ratings the two runs produce. The range tells you how much the uncertain count matters.
Read the fastest path section before the action list. It names the smallest combination of factors to clear for the next better rating, plus what clearing each deficient factor alone would do. A carrier short on time should clear the factors the fastest path names first, because those are the fixes that move the rating. A carrier with time should clear every deficient factor, because a Conditional rating with 3 Conditional factors is one finding away from Unsatisfactory at the next review.
Questions carriers ask
What is a good FMCSA safety rating?
Satisfactory is the best rating FMCSA assigns. It means the carrier meets the safety fitness standard in 49 CFR 385.5, with adequate safety management controls in place that function effectively. Conditional means the carrier lacks adequate controls but is not unfit. Unsatisfactory means FMCSA has found the carrier unfit. The operating prohibition follows once the rating becomes final.
How many points make a factor Unsatisfactory?
Two points. Under Appendix B section II.C, a factor scores Satisfactory at zero points, Conditional at 1 point, plus Unsatisfactory at 2 or more points. Each acute violation scores 1 point. Each pattern of critical violations scores 1 point, except a Part 395 critical pattern, which scores 2 points on its own.
How many Unsatisfactory factors mean an Unsatisfactory rating?
Two or more Unsatisfactory factors mean an Unsatisfactory rating on their own. One Unsatisfactory factor also means an Unsatisfactory rating when more than 2 factors are Conditional. One Unsatisfactory factor with 2 or fewer Conditional factors means a Conditional rating. Zero Unsatisfactory factors with more than 2 Conditional factors also means a Conditional rating.
Does the accident rate alone decide the rating?
No. The accident factor is one of six factors. A recordable accident rate above 1.5 per million miles, or above 1.7 for an urban carrier, makes Factor 6 Unsatisfactory, but the overall rating still depends on the other five factors. One Unsatisfactory factor with 2 or fewer Conditional factors means a Conditional rating, not an Unsatisfactory one. The factor is also not rated at all when the carrier has fewer than 2 recordable accidents in the past 12 months.
How long does an Unsatisfactory rating take to become final?
A proposed Unsatisfactory rating becomes final 45 days after the notice for a carrier transporting passengers or hazardous materials in quantities requiring placarding, plus 60 days after the notice for all other carriers, under section 385.11(c). The operating prohibition starts the next day: day 46 or day 61. A property carrier making a good-faith effort may get up to 60 additional days of operation under section 385.17(g).
Can a safety rating be changed after it is assigned?
Yes, two ways. A carrier that believes FMCSA made a factual or procedural error can request an administrative review under section 385.15, within 15 days of a proposed Unsatisfactory notice so FMCSA can decide before the prohibition starts. The outer limit is 90 days. A carrier that has fixed the deficiencies can request a rating change under section 385.17 at any time, with written evidence of the corrective actions.
Related tools
- Safety Rating Explainer: what each rating means plus the full Unsatisfactory countdown from the notice date.
- SMS BASIC Measure Estimator: work out the CSA measure for a BASIC from inspection and violation data.
- FMCSA Fine Calculator: work out the current inflation-adjusted penalty for a given FMCSA violation.
- Crash Preventability Checker: check whether a crash qualifies for a Not Preventable determination under the FMCSA program.
Sources
- 49 CFR Part 385 Appendix B, Explanation of Safety Rating Process (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- 49 CFR 385.5, Safety fitness standard (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; last amended 77 FR 28454, May 14, 2012)
- 49 CFR 385.7, Factors to be considered in determining a safety rating (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- 49 CFR 385.11, Notification of safety fitness determination (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- 49 CFR 385.13, Unsatisfactory rated motor carriers; prohibition on transportation; ineligibility for Federal contracts (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- 49 CFR 385.15, Administrative review (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- 49 CFR 385.17, Change to safety rating based upon corrective actions (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026)
- SAFER Company Snapshot (FMCSA, carrier safety rating lookup)