Skip to main content

Trucking Mind

This tool estimates the measure, never the percentile. FMCSA ranks each measure against carriers with similar safety events to produce a percentile. That peer data is not public. No tool, website, or spreadsheet can compute your real CSA percentile. What this estimator does is work out each BASIC measure from your violations plus inspections, show the intervention threshold that applies to the percentile, plus tell you whether FMCSA has enough data to assign a percentile at all.

An example fleet is loaded below: a 10-truck general carrier with a few violations plus two crashes. Replace every number with your own figures from the SMS site. Every answer updates as you change each field.

Your carrier

Carrier type sets the intervention threshold. Fleet segment sets the utilization factor bands for Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator.

Average power units are the three figures above added together, divided by 3. Find them in the History section of the SMS site.

Use the most recent positive VMT figure from the MCS-150. Enter 0 when no recent VMT is on file; the utilization factor then stays at 1. An acute or critical violation found in an investigation prioritizes the carrier regardless of any percentile.

Unsafe Driving

Enter inspections with an Unsafe Driving violation plus the total severity points for each time band. No out-of-service weight applies in this BASIC. Severity weights run 1 to 10; the 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandInspections with a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

Crash Indicator

Enter state-reported crashes that meet the reportable standard: a fatality, an injury taken for immediate medical attention, or a vehicle towed from the scene. Leave out crashes FMCSA reviewed as not preventable under the Crash Preventability Determination Program. A crash with an HM release counts in its tow-away or injury column plus in the HM release column.

Time bandTow-away onlyInjury or fatalityHM release
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

HOS Compliance

Relevant inspections are driver inspections, Levels 1, 2, 3, or 6, including clean ones. Add 2 points for each violation that put the driver out of service. The 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandRelevant inspectionsWith a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

Vehicle Maintenance

Relevant inspections are vehicle inspections, Levels 1, 2, 5, or 6, including clean ones. Add 2 points for each violation that put the vehicle out of service. The 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandRelevant inspectionsWith a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

Controlled Substances/Alcohol

Relevant inspections are driver inspections, Levels 1, 2, 3, or 6, including clean ones. No out-of-service weight applies in this BASIC, because most violations in this category are already out-of-service violations. The 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandRelevant inspectionsWith a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

Driver Fitness

Relevant inspections are driver inspections, Levels 1, 2, 3, or 6, including clean ones. Add 2 points for each violation that put the driver out of service. The 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandRelevant inspectionsWith a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

HM Compliance

Relevant inspections are vehicle inspections where the carrier was noted as transporting placardable quantities of hazardous materials, including clean ones. Add 2 points for each violation that put the vehicle out of service. The 30-point cap applies per inspection.

Time bandRelevant inspectionsWith a violationSeverity points
0 to 6 months
weight 3
6 to 12 months
weight 2
12 to 24 months
weight 1

5 of 7 BASICs carry enough recent data for FMCSA to assign a percentile. The highest measure is Unsafe Driving at 5.48.

General carrier, combination segment: 10.00 average power units, utilization factor 1.15.

Each measure below divides time- and severity-weighted violations by exposure: relevant inspections for five BASICs, average power units times the utilization factor for Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator. For a general carrier the intervention threshold is 65 percent in Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator, plus HOS Compliance. The other four BASICs use 80 percent. Those thresholds apply to percentiles, not to measures, so no result here sits above or below a threshold. Compare your percentiles with those thresholds on the SMS site.

The checks

CheckResultDetail
Unsafe DrivingAssignedMeasure 5.48 from 63 weighted points over a denominator of 11.50. Safety event group Combination 1. Threshold for a general carrier: 65 percent.
Crash IndicatorAssignedMeasure 0.61 from 7 weighted points over a denominator of 11.50. Safety event group Combination 1. Threshold for a general carrier: 65 percent.
HOS ComplianceAssignedMeasure 1.39 from 64 weighted points over 46 time-weighted inspections. Safety event group Group 3. Threshold for a general carrier: 65 percent.
Vehicle MaintenanceAssignedMeasure 2.65 from 122 weighted points over 46 time-weighted inspections. Safety event group Group 3. Threshold for a general carrier: 80 percent.
Controlled Substances/AlcoholCleanNo violations in this BASIC in the past 24 months. Measure 0.00. FMCSA assigns no percentile without a violation here.
Driver FitnessAssignedMeasure 0.33 from 15 weighted points over 46 time-weighted inspections. Safety event group Group 3. Threshold for a general carrier: 80 percent.
HM ComplianceCleanNo violations in this BASIC in the past 24 months. Measure 0.00. FMCSA assigns no percentile without a violation here.

The figures

FigureValueNote
Average power units10.00Current 10, six months ago 10, eighteen months ago 10, divided by 3.
Utilization factor1.15Combination segment: 80,000 to 160,000 VMT per average PU.
VMT per average PU100,0001,000,000 annual VMT divided by 10.00 average power units.
Unsafe Driving and Crash Indicator denominator11.50Average power units times the utilization factor.
Unsafe Driving measure5.4863 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 11.50.
Crash Indicator measure0.617 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 11.50.
HOS Compliance measure1.3964 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 46 time-weighted relevant inspections.
Vehicle Maintenance measure2.65122 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 46 time-weighted relevant inspections.
Controlled Substances/Alcohol measure0.000 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 46 time-weighted relevant inspections.
Driver Fitness measure0.3315 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 46 time-weighted relevant inspections.
HM Compliance measure0.000 time- and severity-weighted points divided by 11 time-weighted relevant inspections.

What to do

  • Check your live percentiles on the SMS site and compare each one with its intervention threshold.
  • Recent violations carry triple weight. Clean inspections in the next 6 months cut the numerator fastest.
  • Start with Vehicle Maintenance: its 2.65 measure is the highest of the five inspection-based BASICs.
  • Challenge any wrong inspection record through DataQs before the 24-month window closes on it.
  • If a crash was not preventable, check whether it qualifies for a CPDP review. A crash FMCSA reviews as not preventable leaves the measure.

Notes

  • No tool can compute a percentile. Percentiles rank a measure against carriers in the same safety event group. FMCSA holds that peer data. This tool estimates the measure and shows the threshold that applies to the percentile.
  • Severity weights are BASIC-specific. A 5 in Unsafe Driving is not the same crash risk as a 5 in Vehicle Maintenance, so measures cannot be compared across BASICs.
  • The 30-point cap applies per inspection. This tool applies it per time band as 30 points times the inspections with violations in that band, which matches the FMCSA cap when no single inspection passes 30 points.
  • Out-of-service violations add 2 to the severity weight in HOS Compliance, Vehicle Maintenance, Driver Fitness, plus HM Compliance. Add that 2 into the points you enter. Unsafe Driving and Controlled Substances/Alcohol carry no out-of-service weight.
  • Crashes FMCSA reviewed as not preventable under the Crash Preventability Determination Program do not count. Leave those crashes out of the counts above.
  • FMCSA updates SMS results monthly. A violation leaves the measure 24 months after the inspection date.

This estimator applies the FMCSA SMS Methodology version 3.21 to the figures you enter. Confirm the result against your live SMS data before acting on it.

Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.

Disclaimer: This tool estimates BASIC measures from the figures you enter plus the FMCSA SMS Methodology version 3.21. It cannot compute a percentile — only FMCSA holds the peer data behind percentiles. Confirm your live percentiles on the SMS site before acting on a result.

Quick answer: FMCSA takes 24 months of roadside inspection violations plus state-reported crashes, weights each event by severity plus recency, divides by exposure, then ranks the result against similar carriers to produce a percentile from 0 to 100 in each of seven BASICs. A percentile at or above the intervention threshold puts the carrier in line for intervention. For a general carrier that threshold is 65 percent in Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator, plus HOS Compliance. The other four BASICs use 80 percent. This SMS BASIC measure estimator works out the measure behind the percentile for each BASIC, shows the threshold that applies, plus explains whether FMCSA has enough data to assign a percentile at all.

Last reviewed: · Focus keyword: how is CSA score calculated

How is a CSA score calculated?

CSA stands for Compliance, Safety, Accountability, the FMCSA program that identifies carriers at risk of a crash. The Safety Measurement System, SMS for short, does the scoring. It pulls 24 months of roadside inspection results plus state-reported crashes, turns them into a measure for each of seven BASICs, then ranks each measure against similar carriers to produce a percentile from 0 to 100. Higher is worse. A percentile of 80 means the carrier has a higher measure than 80 percent of its peer group.

There is no single CSA score. A carrier holds seven percentiles, one per BASIC. FMCSA judges each one separately against its own intervention threshold. A carrier can sit at 30 in Vehicle Maintenance while sitting at 90 in Unsafe Driving. The 90 is the problem, not the average of the two. That is why the estimator on this page works BASIC by BASIC instead of giving one blended number.

The calculation runs in four steps. First, FMCSA collects the raw events: violations from roadside inspections plus crashes from state reports over the past 24 months. Second, it weights each event: a severity weight from 1 to 10 for the crash risk of the violation, multiplied by a time weight of 3, 2, or 1 for how recent the event is. Third, it divides the weighted total by exposure to get the BASIC measure. Fourth, it ranks that measure against carriers with similar safety events to produce the percentile. The percentile, not the measure, is what FMCSA compares with the intervention threshold.

Investigation results sit alongside the on-road math. An acute or critical violation found during an investigation in the past 12 months prioritizes a carrier in that BASIC regardless of the percentile. The estimator asks about that separately, because it changes the verdict even when every measure looks clean.

What are the seven BASICs?

BASIC stands for Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Category. Each one covers a different kind of safety behavior, with its own violations, its own measure, plus its own intervention threshold. The thresholds below come from Table 2-2 of the SMS Methodology version 3.21, the live method as of November 2026.

BASICWhat it coversGeneral carrierPassenger carrierHM carrier
Unsafe DrivingSpeeding, reckless driving, improper lane change, texting, seat belt violations65%50%60%
Crash IndicatorHistory of crash involvement, including frequency plus severity65%50%60%
HOS ComplianceHours-of-service violations, logbook violations, driving while ill or fatigued65%50%60%
Vehicle MaintenanceBrakes, tires, lights, steering, coupling devices, cargo securement80%65%75%
Controlled Substances/AlcoholDrug plus alcohol testing violations, positive tests, refusals80%65%75%
Driver FitnessInvalid CDL, missing medical certificate, unqualified driver80%65%75%
HM CompliancePlacarding, shipping papers, loading plus unloading of hazardous materials80%80%80%

Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator, plus HOS Compliance carry the lower thresholds because FMCSA analysis links them most strongly to future crash involvement. Passenger plus HM carriers face lower thresholds than general carriers in most BASICs, because a crash involving a bus or a hazmat load has worse consequences. HM Compliance uses 80 percent for all three carrier types.

Two BASICs are not public. FMCSA does not show Crash Indicator or HM Compliance percentiles on the public SMS site; the carrier sees its own results by logging in, while the public sees the other five BASICs. That is one more reason the Crash Indicator estimate on this page matters: it is the BASIC a carrier can least easily check from outside.

What is a BASIC measure?

The measure is the number behind the percentile. It is a rate: weighted bad events divided by exposure. A carrier with more trucks, more miles, or more inspections gets a bigger denominator, so the same violations produce a lower measure. That normalization is what makes measures comparable across carriers of different sizes. It is why a raw violation count tells you almost nothing on its own.

Five BASICs divide by inspections. The HOS Compliance, Controlled Substances/Alcohol, plus Driver Fitness measures divide by the total time weight of relevant driver inspections. The Vehicle Maintenance plus HM Compliance measures divide by the total time weight of relevant vehicle inspections. For HM Compliance, only inspections where the carrier was noted as transporting placardable quantities of hazardous materials count. Clean inspections count in the denominator, which is why they help.

Two BASICs divide by fleet size. Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator divide by average power units times the utilization factor. The reason is that speeding plus other moving violations usually prompt the inspection in the first place, so dividing by inspection counts would reward the behavior being measured. Fleet size is the fairer denominator for those two BASICs.

A worked example makes the math concrete. The example fleet loaded in the estimator has 10 power units plus 1,000,000 annual VMT. Its average power units are 10, its VMT per power unit is 100,000, plus its utilization factor is 1.15. The Unsafe Driving numerator is 63 weighted points, so the measure is 63 divided by 11.50, which is 5.48. The HOS Compliance numerator is 64 weighted points over 46 time-weighted inspections, so the measure is 1.39. Lower is better. Zero is best. But a 5.48 in Unsafe Driving cannot be compared with a 1.39 in HOS Compliance, because severity weights are BASIC-specific. Each measure only means something inside its own BASIC.

How do severity weights work?

Every roadside inspection violation carries a severity weight from 1 to 10, set by FMCSA analysis of how strongly that violation links to crash risk, plus input from enforcement experts. The full list sits in Appendix A of the SMS Methodology. A weight of 10 marks the violations most tied to crashes in that BASIC. A weight of 1 marks the least. The weights are BASIC-specific: a 5 in Unsafe Driving is not the same crash risk as a 5 in Vehicle Maintenance, so weights from different BASICs must never be added together.

Out-of-service violations add 2 to the severity weight in four BASICs: HOS Compliance, Vehicle Maintenance, Driver Fitness, plus HM Compliance. Two BASICs carry no out-of-service weight. Unsafe Driving carries none because most violations there are not out-of-service violations. Controlled Substances/Alcohol carries none because most violations there already are. When you enter severity points in the estimator, add the 2 for each out-of-service violation in the four BASICs that use it.

One inspection cannot swamp a BASIC. The sum of severity weights for one inspection in one BASIC is capped at 30, applied before the time weight. A single bad inspection with 45 points of violations counts as 30. The estimator applies that cap per time band as 30 points times the inspections with violations in that band, which matches the FMCSA cap exactly when no single inspection passes 30 points. The cap also explains why spreading violations across many inspections hurts more than stacking them into one.

Two more rules shape the points you enter. When the same violation cite appears more than once on one inspection, the SMS counts it once. And when a citation tied to a violation is adjudicated, the outcome changes the weight: a dismissed citation or a not-guilty finding removes the violation from the SMS, while a conviction on a different charge sets the severity weight to 1 plus drops the out-of-service weight. Those changes flow through a Request for Data Review in DataQs, so a wrong record is worth challenging. The DataQs Challenge Helper works out whether a record is challengeable plus what the filing windows are. To look up the severity weight of any single violation, use the CSA Violation Points and Fall-Off Checker, which covers 126 violations with their weights plus fall-off dates.

How do time weights work?

Recent events count more than old ones. Every violation, inspection, plus crash in the SMS carries a time weight based on its age: 3 for events in the past 6 months, 2 for events over 6 months plus up to 12 months old, 1 for events older than 12 months but within the past 24 months. Events older than 24 months drop out of the measure entirely.

The effect is large. A 10-point violation recorded last month contributes 30 points to the numerator. The same violation at 8 months old contributes 20. At 18 months it contributes 10. At 25 months it contributes nothing. That decay is why a carrier with an old violation history can watch a measure fall month by month without doing anything. It is also why a fresh violation hurts far more than an old one.

The time weight applies to the denominator too. For the five inspection-based BASICs, each relevant inspection contributes its time weight to the denominator: a clean inspection last month adds 3, while a clean inspection 18 months ago adds 1. An old clean inspection fades just like an old violation does, so a carrier that stops getting inspected sees its denominator shrink over time. The measure then rests on fewer, older inspections.

Keep the paperwork that backs your numbers. Inspection reports, crash reports, plus adjudication documents are the evidence behind every DataQs challenge plus every CPDP request. Each record type has its own retention period. The DOT Record Retention Checker lists how long each DOT record must be kept, so nothing is shredded before its time.

What is the utilization factor?

The utilization factor adjusts fleet size for how hard the trucks run. Two carriers with 10 power units are not equally exposed if one runs 40,000 miles per truck per year while the other runs 120,000. The factor multiplies the average power units in the Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator denominators, so a high-mileage fleet gets a bigger denominator plus a lower measure for the same violations.

Average power units come from the carrier census: current power units, plus the count from 6 months ago, plus the count from 18 months ago, all divided by 3. A growing fleet therefore carries a lower average than its current size, which raises its measures until the older counts catch up. A shrinking fleet carries a higher average than its current size, which lowers its measures for a while. Both effects are deliberate: the average smooths sudden fleet changes.

The factor depends on the fleet segment. Combination fleets, where tractors or motor coaches make up 70 percent or more of power units, use one table. Straight fleets, where straight trucks plus other vehicles make up more than 30 percent of power units, use a different table with much higher factors.

Combination segment, VMT per average PUUtilization factor
Under 80,0001
80,000 to 160,0001 + (VMT per PU – 80,000) / 133,333
160,000 to 200,0001.6
Over 200,0001
No recent VMT information1
Straight segment, VMT per average PUUtilization factor
Under 20,0001
20,000 to 60,000VMT per PU / 20,000
60,000 to 200,0003
Over 200,0001
No recent VMT information1

Watch the cliff at 200,000. Above 200,000 VMT per average PU the factor drops back to 1 in both segments, which shrinks the denominator plus raises the measure. A carrier whose VMT per power unit crosses that line sees its Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator measures jump even though nothing about its safety changed. That is why the VMT figure on the MCS-150 matters so much: an overstated VMT number can push a carrier over the cliff, while an understated one leaves factor on the table. Carriers must update the MCS-150 at least every 24 months. The MCS-150 Due Date Checker shows when the next update falls due.

When does FMCSA assign a percentile?

FMCSA does not assign a percentile on thin data. Each BASIC has a data sufficiency minimum. A carrier below it shows no percentile at all. The estimator checks every minimum for you, so a low measure never gets mistaken for a clean percentile.

BASICMinimum for a percentile
Unsafe Driving3 inspections with a violation
Crash Indicator2 reportable crashes
HOS Compliance3 relevant driver inspections, plus at least 1 with a violation
Vehicle Maintenance5 relevant vehicle inspections, plus at least 1 with a violation
Controlled Substances/Alcohol1 inspection with a violation
Driver Fitness5 relevant driver inspections, plus at least 1 with a violation
HM Compliance5 relevant inspections, plus at least 1 with a violation

Meeting the minimum is only the first test. FMCSA also drops the percentile when the BASIC goes quiet. In Unsafe Driving, Controlled Substances/Alcohol, plus Crash Indicator, the percentile disappears when no event in the BASIC falls in the past 12 months. In HOS Compliance, Vehicle Maintenance, Driver Fitness, plus HM Compliance, it disappears when no violation falls in the past 12 months and the latest relevant inspection had no violation in that BASIC. A carrier that cleans up its act therefore loses its percentile after a year, which is a good outcome: no percentile means no prioritization from that BASIC.

Carriers that pass both tests land in a safety event group, a peer group based on how many safety events they have. Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator split further by fleet segment, combination or straight. A carrier with 3 inspections with violations is ranked only against carriers with a similar count, never against a fleet with 500. The group is part of why the percentile cannot be computed without peer data: the rank depends on who else sits in the group.

Why can no tool show your real CSA percentile?

A percentile is a rank, not a measurement. To compute one you need every carrier measure in the safety event group, sorted from lowest to highest, so you can count how many sit below yours. FMCSA holds that peer data. It is not published, not available through an API, plus not recoverable from any public dataset. Any website that claims to compute your CSA percentile from your own numbers alone is guessing. The guess has no basis in the methodology.

The measure is different. The measure depends only on your own data: your violations, your inspections, your power units, plus your VMT. That is why this estimator can compute it honestly. The measure tells you the direction of travel: whether a BASIC is getting better or worse month by month, which BASIC carries the most weighted points, plus whether FMCSA has enough data to assign a percentile. What it cannot tell you is where the measure lands in the peer ranking. That ranking is the percentile.

The honest workflow is therefore two steps. Use the estimator to understand your measures plus your data sufficiency. Then log in to the SMS site to read your actual percentiles. Compare each one with the intervention threshold for your carrier type. The estimator shows the threshold beside every BASIC so the comparison takes seconds once you have the percentile in front of you.

What happens when a BASIC crosses its threshold?

Crossing an intervention threshold does not produce a fine on its own. It produces a symbol in that BASIC plus prioritization for intervention. FMCSA works through a ladder of interventions, starting light. A warning letter is the usual first step: a letter naming the BASIC plus the safety problem, with no penalty attached. Many carriers fix the problem at that stage and never climb further.

If the percentile stays high, FMCSA moves to investigations. An offsite investigation reviews records remotely. An onsite focused investigation looks at the BASICs that tripped the threshold. An onsite comprehensive investigation covers the whole safety program. Investigators can find acute plus critical violations during any of these. Those findings can change a safety rating. The Safety Rating Explainer walks through how Satisfactory, Conditional, plus Unsatisfactory ratings are decided, plus what each one means for the business.

Fines enter the picture only when an investigation or a roadside enforcement action produces a Notice of Claim. The penalty depends on the violation plus the carrier history, not on the percentile itself. The FMCSA Fines Calculator estimates the penalty range for common violations. A high percentile is best treated as an early warning, not as a bill: the cheapest time to fix a BASIC is before FMCSA opens a file on it.

How do you lower a BASIC measure?

Clean inspections are the fastest lever for the five inspection-based BASICs. Every clean inspection adds time-weighted inspections to the denominator while adding nothing to the numerator, so the measure falls. A carrier with a high Vehicle Maintenance measure that runs a month of clean inspections will see the measure drop at the next monthly update. The same logic does not apply to Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator, where the denominator is fleet size: there, only fewer violations plus fewer crashes move the measure.

Fix the repeat violation types first. The measure is a sum, so the violations that appear most often plus carry the highest weights dominate it. Pull the inspection history, sort the violations by cite, then fix the top two or three. A brake violation worth 4 points that appears on every third inspection costs more over 24 months than a single 10-point violation. Driver coaching, pre-trip inspection discipline, plus maintenance scheduling all pay off in the measure within months.

Challenge wrong data. An inspection record with the wrong violation, the wrong vehicle, or the wrong carrier can sit in the measure for 24 months unless someone challenges it. DataQs is the channel. The DataQs Challenge Helper works out the filing windows plus the evidence needed. Adjudicated citations help too: a dismissed citation removes the violation. A conviction on a different charge drops its weight to 1.

For crashes, check preventability. A crash FMCSA reviews as not preventable under the Crash Preventability Determination Program leaves the Crash Indicator measure plus percentile entirely. The Crash Preventability Checker tests whether a crash falls into one of the 21 eligible types. Not every crash qualifies. The evidence bar is real, but a qualifying crash removed from the measure is worth more than any other single fix in that BASIC.

Time does the rest. Every violation loses a third of its weight at 6 months, half of what remains at 12 months, plus everything at 24 months. A carrier that stops adding violations watches each measure decay on a fixed schedule. The estimator shows the time bands separately so you can see exactly which violations are about to lose weight.

What is changing in SMS?

FMCSA approved a revised SMS methodology on November 20, 2024, published as 89 FR 91874. The revision renames the BASICs as safety categories, regroups roughly 2,000 violation codes into about 100 violation groups, splits Vehicle Maintenance into what an inspector can see on a walk-around plus what only turns up in a shop, folds Controlled Substances/Alcohol into Unsafe Driving, plus simplifies the severity weights. It is a large redesign, not a tune-up.

As of October 2026 the revision is not live. FMCSA runs it as a preview only: carriers can log in to the CSA Prioritization Preview to see how their own results would look under the new method, while every live SMS result still uses the seven BASICs under Methodology version 3.21. FMCSA has published no launch date. Its November 2024 notice says a separate Federal Register notice will announce the date when it comes. FMCSA told carriers to keep using the current SMS until the new system takes effect.

Version 3.21 is therefore the method that matters today. It added 19 violations plus updated the descriptions of 11 violations, effective with the May 15, 2026 SMS snapshot. This estimator follows version 3.21 throughout. When FMCSA announces a launch date for the revised method, the estimator will need a rebuild against the new categories plus weights. The review date on this page is the prompt to check.

How do you use the SMS BASIC Measure Estimator?

Work through the fields in order. The estimator updates with every change, so you can fix an answer plus watch the measures move.

  1. Pull your last 24 months of inspections plus crashes from the SMS site.
  2. Enter your carrier type, fleet segment, power units, plus annual VMT.
  3. Enter the violations plus inspections for each BASIC by time band.
  4. Enter reportable crashes by type plus time band, leaving out crashes FMCSA reviewed as not preventable.
  5. Read the measure for each BASIC, plus whether FMCSA has enough data to assign a percentile.
  6. Compare your live percentiles with the intervention thresholds on the SMS site.

Before you rely on a result, confirm the severity points against the inspection reports. The estimator trusts the points you enter. A severity weight read from the wrong BASIC, or an out-of-service 2 left out, changes the measure. The CSA Violation Points and Fall-Off Checker lists the weight for each violation cite, so check any cite you are unsure about before entering it.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good CSA score?

A low percentile is good. Zero is best. A percentile tells you how a carrier ranks against similar carriers, so a 20 in Unsafe Driving means 80 percent of the peer group has a lower measure. Anything below the intervention threshold avoids prioritization. For a general carrier that means under 65 percent in Unsafe Driving, Crash Indicator, plus HOS Compliance, plus under 80 percent in the other four BASICs. A carrier with no violations in a BASIC has a measure of zero in that BASIC, which is the best possible result.

How long do violations stay on a CSA score?

Violations count in the SMS for 24 months from the inspection date, then drop out of the measure. Their weight falls over that period: full triple weight in the first 6 months, double weight from 6 to 12 months, single weight from 12 to 24 months. A violation never disappears from the inspection record itself, but it stops affecting the measure after 24 months.

Can a carrier have a CSA score of zero?

Yes. In a BASIC with no violations or crashes in the past 24 months the measure is zero, which is the best possible result. FMCSA may show no percentile at all for that BASIC when the carrier has no violations there, because a percentile needs at least one safety event in most BASICs. A zero measure plus no percentile is the cleanest result a carrier can hold.

Why is the Crash Indicator not public?

FMCSA does not show Crash Indicator percentiles to the public. The same applies to HM Compliance. The agency keeps those two BASICs visible only to the carrier plus enforcement, because crash involvement alone does not prove fault. A carrier can see its own Crash Indicator percentile by logging in to the SMS site. Shippers plus insurers see the other five BASICs.

Do clean inspections help a CSA score?

Yes. Clean inspections add to the denominator of the measure for the five inspection-based BASICs, which pulls the measure down even when the violation total stays the same. A clean inspection also counts toward the data sufficiency minimums. For Unsafe Driving plus Crash Indicator, clean inspections do not change the denominator, because those two BASICs normalize by fleet size instead.

How often does FMCSA update SMS scores?

FMCSA updates SMS results monthly. A snapshot of the data is taken on the third or last Friday of each month, then takes about 10 days to process plus validate before the new results publish. A violation from an inspection this week normally appears in the next monthly update, not the same day.

Related tools

Sources

  • FMCSA Safety Measurement System (SMS) Methodology, version 3.21 (document revised June 2026: measure formulas, severity weights, time weights, utilization factor tables 3-1 plus 3-2, intervention thresholds Table 2-2, data sufficiency standards, safety event groups; downloaded Nov 19, 2026)
  • FMCSA Safety Measurement System (live carrier SMS results, percentiles, plus inspection plus crash history; read Nov 19, 2026)
  • FMCSA Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) Program (program overview plus SMS help center; read Nov 19, 2026)
  • FMCSA CSA Prioritization Preview (revised SMS methodology in preview only, not live, no launch date published; read Nov 19, 2026)
  • FMCSA DataQs (Request for Data Review system for challenging inspection plus crash data; read Nov 19, 2026)
  • FMCSA Crash Preventability Determination Program, fmcsa.dot.gov/crash-preventability-determination-program (21 eligible crash types for crashes on or after Dec 1, 2024; determinations posted to SMS plus PSP within 60 days; page confirmed live Nov 19, 2026, automated fetch blocked)
Follow on WhatsApp Ask by Voice