This tool checks one transaction record against 49 CFR 371.3. Brokers: tick each element the record shows, then read the verdict plus the retention date. Carriers: answer the waiver, request, plus response questions to see what the review right covers for this load. The pending FMCSA transparency proposal is not in force, so this tool applies the current rule only.
Pick your role first. The questions change with the role. Every answer updates the result as you change each field.
Enter the date as YYYY-MM-DD or MM/DD/YYYY. The 3 year retention clock runs from this date.
The six record elements, section 371.3(a)
Element (5) covers any service beyond arranging the transportation, such as detention negotiation or claims help. When no such service was performed, element (5) has nothing to record.
Record keeping
Record incomplete.
6 checks passed, 1 check failed, 0 not applicable.
This record is missing 1 of the 6 elements that apply to this transaction under section 371.3(a). A broker record must show every element that applies. Add the missing elements, then run this check again. The 3 year retention period for this transaction runs to November 19, 2026.
The checks
| Requirement | Result | Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Consignor name and address, section 371.3(a)(1) | Pass | The name plus address of the consignor are on the record. |
| Originating carrier name, address, plus registration number, section 371.3(a)(2) | Pass | The name, address, plus registration number of the originating motor carrier are on the record. |
| Bill of lading or freight bill number, section 371.3(a)(3) | Pass | The bill of lading or freight bill number is on the record. |
| Brokerage compensation and payer name, section 371.3(a)(4) | Pass | The amount of compensation received for the brokerage service plus the name of the payer are on the record. |
| Non-brokerage services, section 371.3(a)(5) | Pass | The description of each non-brokerage service, the amount of compensation for it, plus the name of the payer are on the record. |
| Freight charges collected and date of payment, section 371.3(a)(6) | Fail | The amount of freight charges collected is on the record, but the date of payment to the carrier is missing. Element (6) requires both. |
| Record retained for 3 years, section 371.3(b) | Pass | The record is still kept. Keep it until November 19, 2026. 0 days left, the period ends today. |
The figures
| Figure | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction date | November 19, 2023 | The date of the brokered transaction. The 3 year retention clock in this tool runs from this date. |
| Retention expiry date | November 19, 2026 | Section 371.3(b): brokers shall keep the records required by this section for a period of three years. |
| Days remaining in the retention period | 0 days left, the period ends today | After the period runs, the regulation no longer requires the record. |
| Elements recorded | 5 of 6 | Elements that do not apply to this transaction, such as non-brokerage services when none were performed, are not counted. |
| Missing elements | Date of payment to the carrier (6) | Add each missing element to the record, then run this check again. |
| Master lists | No | Without a master list, each transaction record must carry the full consignor plus carrier details itself. |
What to do
- Add the date of payment to the carrier to the record. Element (6) requires the date as well as the amount.
What to keep with the record
- A copy of the bill of lading or freight bill for the load.
- The rate confirmation plus the broker carrier agreement for the transaction.
- The settlement sheet showing the compensation received plus the payer.
- Proof of payment to the carrier, with the payment date, for element (6).
- A log of review requests under section 371.3(c), with the date of each request plus the reply.
Notes
- Section 371.3(b) names a period of three years but does not name the starting day. This tool counts the three years from the transaction date.
- A broker may keep master lists of consignors and of the carrier address plus registration number rather than repeating that information for each transaction. The master list must be current.
- Element (5) applies only when a non-brokerage service was performed. Element (6) applies only when the broker collected freight charges on the transaction.
- Household goods brokers serving individual shippers follow Subpart B of Part 371, starting at section 371.101. This tool covers property broker records under Subpart A.
- Pending rulemaking status checked November 19, 2026: the supplemental proposal is pending OIRA review since August 27, 2026. No final rule, no compliance date.
This tool applies 49 CFR 371.3 to your inputs. Confirm the result against the regulation text plus the transaction documents before acting. A wrong transaction date gives a wrong retention date, so check the date against the bill of lading.
Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.
Disclaimer: This tool is a planning estimate based on the published text of 49 CFR Part 371, not legal advice — confirm the result plus any fix with FMCSA, a qualified transportation attorney, or your legal counsel before relying on it in a dispute.
Quick answer: A property broker must keep a record of each transaction under 49 CFR 371.3. Each record must show six elements: the consignor name plus address, the originating carrier name plus address plus registration number, the bill of lading or freight bill number, the brokerage compensation received plus the payer name, any non-brokerage services with their compensation plus payer, plus any freight charges collected plus the date of payment to the carrier. The broker must keep the record for three years. Each party to the transaction, carrier plus consignor alike, has the right to review the record under section 371.3(c). The FMCSA transparency proposal would add electronic records plus a 48 hour deadline, but it is still pending review at the White House, so none of it is in force. This checker tests one transaction record against the six elements, works out the retention expiry date, plus tells a carrier what the review right covers on that load.
What records must a freight broker keep?
Section 371.3(a) of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations sets the rule in one sentence: a broker shall keep a record of each transaction. The regulation then lists what the record shall show, in six numbered elements. A record that misses one element that applies to the transaction is incomplete, however thorough the rest of it may be. The checker above tests each element in turn, then works out the retention date from the transaction date.
| Element | What the record must show | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| (1) Consignor | The name plus address of the consignor | Every transaction |
| (2) Originating carrier | The name, address, plus registration number of the originating motor carrier | Every transaction |
| (3) Bill number | The bill of lading or freight bill number | Every transaction |
| (4) Brokerage compensation | The amount of compensation received by the broker for the brokerage service plus the name of the payer | Every transaction |
| (5) Non-brokerage services | A description of any non-brokerage service performed, the amount of compensation for the service, plus the name of the payer | Only when such a service was performed |
| (6) Freight charges collected | The amount of any freight charges collected by the broker plus the date of payment to the carrier | Only when the broker collected freight charges |
Two of the six elements are conditional, which is where most checklists go wrong. Element (5) applies only when a non-brokerage service was performed in connection with the shipment or other activity. A non-brokerage service is any service beyond arranging the transportation: detention negotiation, claims help, tracking updates sold as a service, or lumpers arranged by the broker. When no such service was performed, element (5) has nothing to record. The checker marks it not applicable rather than failed. Element (6) applies only when the broker collected freight charges on the transaction. When the shipper paid the carrier directly and the broker never touched the freight charges, element (6) has nothing to record either.
Element (6) also carries the most commonly missed half of the whole rule. The regulation requires two facts, not one: the amount of any freight charges collected by the broker plus the date of payment to the carrier. A record that shows the amount but not the payment date fails element (6). Brokerage software often stores the amount in the settlement screen and the payment date in the accounting screen, so the two facts live apart and the record as a whole misses one. The checker tests them separately for exactly that reason. If your record shows the amount, tick the first box. If it also shows the payment date, tick the second. The default state of this checker shows the failure: a record with everything except the payment date reads as incomplete.
The regulation also allows a shortcut for the two elements that repeat on every load. Section 371.3(a) says brokers may keep master lists of consignors and the address and registration number of the carrier, rather than repeating this information for each transaction. A broker with a standing book of shippers and a carrier base does not need to print the full consignor address and carrier registration number on every transaction record, provided the master lists exist and are current. The checker has a master list toggle for this. Tick it when the master lists cover elements (1) and (2). The detail for those checks notes the master list. A master list that has gone stale, with an old address or a revoked registration number, does not cover the record: the list must match the transaction.
What counts as a record is practical, not formal. The current rule sets no required format, no required medium, plus no required layout. A transport management system entry that holds the six elements is a record. A paper file with the bill of lading, the rate confirmation, plus the settlement sheet is a record. A spreadsheet that holds the elements is a record. What matters is that the six elements are there and can be produced when a party asks to review them. The pending FMCSA proposal would require electronic records, which would end the paper-only option, but that change is not in force. The current rule cares about content, not form.
The record rule covers property brokers under Subpart A of Part 371. Household goods brokers serving individual shippers follow a separate set of rules in Subpart B, starting at section 371.101. This tool does not test those. A household goods broker serving commercial or government shippers sits outside Subpart B. If you broker household goods for individual shippers, check the Subpart B requirements as well as the record rule here.
Carrier record retention follows different clocks. A carrier keeps driver qualification files, hours of service records, vehicle inspection reports, plus drug and alcohol testing records under separate retention rules in Parts 382, 390, 391, 395, plus 396, with periods from six months to five years. The DOT Record Retention Checker works out those carrier clocks. This tool covers the broker side only, where the clock is a single three year period under section 371.3(b).
How long must a broker keep transaction records?
Three years. Section 371.3(b) says brokers shall keep the records required by this section for a period of three years. The period is the same for every transaction, every broker, plus every element. There is no shorter period for small brokers, no longer period for large ones, plus no exception for transactions that went wrong. The clock is the same whether the load paid well or ended in a claim.
The regulation does not name the starting day of the three years. It says the records shall be kept for a period of three years, without saying three years from what. The working reading, the one this tool applies, counts the three years from the transaction date. A transaction dated November 19, 2023 carries a retention expiry of November 19, 2026. A transaction dated June 15, 2024 carries an expiry of June 15, 2027. The checker shows the expiry date plus the days remaining, so a broker can see at a glance whether a record is still inside its window. State that reading openly if a dispute turns on it: the starting day is the tool interpretation, not a quoted line of the regulation.
Worked example: a broker arranges a load on February 29, 2024, a leap day. Three years later falls on February 29, 2027, a date that does not exist. This tool counts the expiry as February 28, 2027, the last day of February in the expiry year. A broker who keeps the record to February 28, 2027 has kept it for the full period under any reading. A broker who destroys it on February 27, 2027 has not. The leap day edge is rare, but it shows why the retention date deserves a calculation rather than a guess.
After the period runs, the duty ends. A broker who destroys a record after the three years have run has broken no rule. A broker who destroys a record inside the window has. The distinction matters in practice because transport management systems, email archives, plus paper files all get purged on schedules of their own. A broker whose system auto-deletes transaction records after two years is destroying records a full year early. The deletion is a violation whether or not anyone ever asked to see the record. Check the purge settings in the transport management system plus the email retention policy against the three year clock. If either purges sooner, the settings need to change.
Keeping records past the three years is allowed, plus often wise. A payment dispute can surface after the retention period has run. A carrier can ask about a load from four years ago. A broker who kept the record can answer from the file. A broker who destroyed it on the expiry date can only answer from memory. The regulation sets a floor, not a ceiling. Nothing in Part 371 punishes a broker for keeping a record for five years or ten. The checker marks a record that is still kept after its expiry date as passing, with a note that the regulation no longer requires it.
The retention clock also decides whether a carrier review request has any force. A carrier who asks to see a record inside the three year window asks for a record the broker must still hold. A carrier who asks after the window has run asks for a record the broker may lawfully have destroyed. The carrier side of this checker tests exactly that: enter the transaction date. The retention check tells you whether the window is still open. If it has run, ask anyway. The broker may still hold the record in a transport management system even though the regulation no longer requires it. But the request no longer carries the weight of the rule behind it.
What can a carrier see under section 371.3(c)?
Section 371.3(c) gives the right in one sentence: each party to a brokered transaction has the right to review the record of the transaction required to be kept by these rules. The word that matters is each. The right belongs to every party, not only to the carrier. The consignor holds it too. The broker cannot pick which party may look. A carrier who hauled the load is a party. A shipper who tendered it is a party. Both may ask.
What the carrier may see is the whole record, not a summary of it. The record is the six elements in section 371.3(a), so the review right covers all six, including element (4): the amount of compensation received by the broker for the brokerage service plus the name of the payer. That figure is the one carriers most want to see, because it shows the spread between what the shipper paid and what the carrier received. It is also the figure brokers most resist showing. The regulation does not let a broker show five elements and withhold the compensation figure. The record is the record. The right covers it whole.
The current rule sets no procedure for asking. There is no required form, no required wording, plus no deadline for the broker to answer. The practical advice is to ask in writing, cite section 371.3(c), name the load, give the bill of lading number, plus keep a copy of the request. A written request creates a paper trail. A phone call does not. If the broker refuses, the refusal in writing plus the request in writing are the evidence a complaint needs. The carrier side of this checker walks through exactly that sequence: waiver, request, response.
The practical reality is less clean than the regulation. FMCSA noted in the 2024 proposal that brokers avoid meaningful compliance by delaying the availability of records for review, plus by restricting access for review to their principal place of business. A carrier based in Texas gains little from a right to review a record that sits in a filing cabinet in Chicago. The 2024 proposal would fix both problems by requiring the broker to provide the records electronically within 48 hours of a request. Neither fix is in force. Under the current rule, a broker who makes the record available only at its office, plus only after a long delay, is testing the edge of the rule rather than breaking a clear deadline, because the rule sets no deadline at all.
When a broker refuses outright, the next step is a complaint to FMCSA through the National Consumer Complaint Database. FMCSA said in the 2024 proposal that it received at least 32 complaints about broker transparency from 2018 through 2020. The volume of interest since then has been intense. A complaint needs the paper trail: the written request, the refusal, the load details, plus the broker name and MC number. Before the next load with an unknown broker, check the broker standing first: authority, bond, plus filings history through the Broker Credit Check. A broker with a thin record habit often shows other warning signs in the same place. The Broker Credit and Safety Verification Checklist runs the eight checks to make before accepting a load from a broker you have not worked with before.
One more limit on the right deserves a plain statement. The review right covers the record the broker must keep, not the broker entire business. A carrier may see the six elements for that transaction. A carrier may not demand the broker rate sheet, the shipper contract, the margin on other loads, or the broker internal correspondence. The right is transaction by transaction. Ask for the record of the load you hauled, by its bill of lading number. The request stays inside the rule.
What is the rate confirmation waiver problem?
The waiver clause is the reason the review right reads better on paper than it works on the road. Rate confirmations, plus the broker carrier agreements behind them, commonly contain a clause in which the carrier waives the right to review the broker transaction record under section 371.3(c). A carrier who signs the rate confirmation signs the waiver with it. When the carrier later asks to see the record, the broker points at the clause and refuses. The regulation gives the right with one hand. The contract takes it back with the other.
FMCSA addressed the waiver question directly in the 2024 proposal. Its answer surprised both sides. The agency said that as a general principle, parties are permitted to waive any right unless Congress, by statute, specifically makes a right non-waivable. FMCSA looked for a statute that bars waivers of the review right and found none. On that reasoning, the agency declined to include the waiver ban that the OOIDA petition plus the SBTC petition had both asked for. The 2024 proposal does not ban waiver clauses. Any carrier who reads that the proposal bans them is reading a summary, not the proposal.
What the proposal does instead is reframe the disclosure requirement. Under the current rule, the review right is phrased as a private right belonging to the carrier or shipper. A private right can be waived. The proposal would rewrite section 371.3(c) so that disclosure becomes a regulatory obligation imposed on the broker: the broker must provide the transaction records to the transacting parties on request. A regulated entity must adhere to the regulations and cannot disguise its regulatory obligations as contractual ones, as the Federal Circuit put it in Taylor Energy Co. LLC v. United States, 975 F.3d 1303, 1306 (2020). If disclosure is a duty the broker owes to the regulator, a contract clause cannot waive it away, because the carrier never owned the duty in the first place. That is the mechanism. It is clever. It is still only a proposal.
The history behind the waiver fight runs back to 2020. OOIDA plus the Small Business in Transportation Coalition petitioned FMCSA that year, asking the agency to require automatic electronic records within 48 hours of completed service plus an explicit ban on waiver clauses. FMCSA asked for public comment at 85 FR 51145 in August 2020 and received 1,391 comments. The Transportation Intermediaries Association petitioned the other way, asking FMCSA to delete section 371.3(c) altogether. In March 2023, FMCSA granted the carrier petitions plus rejected the TIA petition. The 2024 proposal followed from that grant. It drew close to 7,000 comments across its two comment periods, which shows how much the waiver question matters to the industry.
A waiver clause is not the same as a confidentiality clause. The distinction matters. A waiver clause signs the review right away before the carrier ever sees the record. A confidentiality clause limits what the carrier may do with the record after seeing it, such as sharing the compensation figure with non-parties. The 2024 proposal would not prohibit confidentiality clauses. FMCSA said that as long as brokers comply with the requirement to disclose records on request, the parties may negotiate agreements on non-disclosure of the information to non-parties. A carrier who signs a confidentiality clause can still see the record. A carrier who signs a waiver clause cannot.
What should a carrier do about a waiver clause today, while the proposal is still pending? Three things. First, read the rate confirmation plus the broker carrier agreement before signing, plus look for the waiver language. Second, ask for the clause to be struck. A broker may refuse, as many will, but the ask costs nothing. A broker who agrees has given up the workaround. Third, ask in writing anyway when the load is done, plus keep the reply. A refusal on paper is the evidence a complaint needs. A pattern of refusals is what moves a rulemaking. The carrier side of this checker treats a signed waiver as a failed check, because that is what it is in practice: the clause stands between the carrier and the record.
What would the FMCSA transparency proposal change?
The FMCSA transparency proposal would change the broker record rule more than any amendment since the rule was written in 1980. It would also change nothing until it becomes a final rule, which it has not. This section keeps the two piles separate: what the proposal would do, plus where it stands.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| 2020 | OOIDA plus SBTC petition FMCSA for automatic electronic records plus a waiver ban |
| August 19, 2020 | FMCSA asks for comment on the petitions, 85 FR 51145; 1,391 comments received |
| March 2023 | FMCSA grants the carrier petitions, rejects the TIA petition to delete section 371.3(c) |
| November 20, 2024 | NPRM published, 89 FR 91648, Docket FMCSA-2023-0257, RIN 2126-AC63 |
| February 18, 2025 | Comment period reopened, 90 FR 9702, through March 20, 2025 |
| August 27, 2026 | Supplemental proposal sent to OIRA for review |
| November 19, 2026 | Status checked: still pending OIRA review, no final rule, no compliance date |
The 2024 proposal would make four changes to the record rule. First, brokers would keep their transaction records in electronic form, so carriers and shippers could review them remotely rather than only at the broker principal place of business. Second, the records would itemize all charges and fees associated with the brokerage service, with an amount plus a description of each charge and fee, plus any penalties assessed in connection with the shipment, such as a penalty for late delivery or cargo damage. Third, the records would show the date of payment for each service performed in connection with each shipment, extending the date-of-payment idea that already sits in element (6) to every service on the record. Fourth, brokers would provide the records within 48 hours of a request from a party to the transaction, with the responsibility for delivering the information placed on the broker rather than on the requester.
Underneath those four changes sits the reframe described in the waiver section: disclosure would become an affirmative regulatory duty of the broker, not a private right of the carrier. The proposal also states plainly what it would not do. It would not ban waiver clauses outright, for the reason given above. It would not prohibit confidentiality clauses. It would not create a new penalty schedule: FMCSA said the existing penalties in Part 386 Appendix B already cover violations of the commercial regulations, so no new enforcement mechanism is proposed. A broker who reads the proposal as a waiver ban, or as a new fine schedule, is misreading it.
The supplemental proposal is the open question. After the administration changed, FMCSA chose not to finalize the 2024 text and to re-propose instead. The supplemental notice went to the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs on August 27, 2026. The text stays confidential until OIRA clears it, so nobody outside the review process can say whether the supplemental version is stronger or weaker than the 2024 version. When OIRA clears it, the proposal publishes in the Federal Register with a fresh comment period, typically 60 days. A final rule follows only after that comment cycle plus a further round of review. A binding requirement is a 2027 question at the earliest.
The OIRA clock is worth watching. Executive Order 12866 gives OIRA up to 90 days to review a proposal, extendable once by 30 days at the request of the agency head. The 90 day window from August 27, 2026 runs to November 25, 2026. With one extension, it runs to December 25, 2026. OIRA may also return a rule to the agency for reconsideration rather than clearing it, so submission is not the same as approval. The OIRA entry lists the action as a proposed rule, not economically significant, with no legal deadline. This tool checked the OIRA listing on November 19, 2026. It still shows the rulemaking as pending review. The status box in the notes below the tool carries that checked date. At the next review of this page, around May 18, 2027, the OIRA status is the first item to re-check.
Until a final rule publishes with a compliance date, the current rule governs. A broker who keeps electronic records already is ahead of the proposal, not behind it. A broker who waits for the final rule before changing anything is compliant today, provided the six elements are on the record and the record is kept for three years. A carrier who demands records within 48 hours today is demanding a deadline that does not exist yet. The checker applies the current rule only. It says so in the warning box at the top of the tool.
Who counts as a broker under section 371.2?
Section 371.2 defines a broker as a person who, for compensation, arranges, or offers to arrange, the transportation of property by an authorized motor carrier. The definition turns on what the person does, not on what the person calls the business. A company that arranges freight for compensation is a broker under the regulation, whatever name it trades under. The record rule, the misrepresentation rule, plus the accounting rule all follow from that definition.
The definition carries a carve-out for carriers and their agents. Motor carriers, or persons who are employees or bona fide agents of carriers, are not brokers when they arrange or offer to arrange the transportation of shipments which they are authorized to transport and which they have accepted and legally bound themselves to transport. A carrier that arranges the movement of a load it will haul itself is acting as a carrier, not as a broker. A carrier that arranges a load for another carrier to haul, for compensation, crosses into broker territory on that transaction.
A bona fide agent is a defined term, not a label a carrier can stick on any contractor. Section 371.2 says bona fide agents are persons who are part of the normal organization of a motor carrier and perform duties under the carrier directions pursuant to a preexisting agreement which provides for a continuing relationship, precluding the exercise of discretion on the part of the agent in allocating traffic between the carrier and others. The test has three parts: the agent belongs to the carrier normal organization, works under a preexisting agreement with a continuing relationship, plus exercises no discretion in allocating traffic between the carrier and others. An agent who shops a load among several carriers is exercising exactly the discretion the definition forbids. The bona fide agent label does not protect that arrangement.
The section also defines the two kinds of service that matter for the record. Brokerage service is the arranging of transportation or the physical movement of a motor vehicle or of property, performed on behalf of a motor carrier, consignor, or consignee. Non-brokerage service is all other service performed by a broker on behalf of a motor carrier, consignor, or consignee. The distinction decides what element (5) of the record must show. Arranging the load is brokerage service, recorded under element (4). Everything else the broker does for a party, from detention negotiation to claims help, is non-brokerage service, recorded under element (5) with its own compensation plus payer.
The definition matters at the edges of the industry. A dispatcher who arranges transportation for compensation for more than one carrier is doing what the definition describes. The record rule applies. A load board that merely lists loads without arranging transportation is not. The line between arranging and listing is fact-specific. FMCSA has issued guidance on it, but the definition itself is the starting point: compensation plus arranging equals broker. When in doubt, the safe course is to keep the record. A record kept unnecessarily costs a file entry. A record not kept when the rule required it costs a violation.
What else does Part 371 require of brokers?
The record rule is one of several duties in Part 371. A broker who keeps perfect records can still fail the part. Four more sections bind every property broker. Each one is short enough to state in full.
Section 371.7, misrepresentation, has two rules. A broker shall not perform or offer to perform any brokerage service, including advertising, in any name other than that in which its registration is issued. A broker registered under one name cannot trade under another, run a second brand, or advertise under a trade name that is not on the registration. A broker shall not, directly or indirectly, represent its operations to be that of a carrier. Any advertising shall show the broker status of the operation. A broker website, load board posting, or truck-side advertisement that leaves a reader thinking the broker is the carrier breaks this section. The fix is simple: say broker, in the name on the registration, on every public face of the business.
Section 371.9, rebating and compensation, has two rules of its own. A broker shall not charge or receive compensation from a motor carrier for brokerage service where the broker owns or has a material beneficial interest in the shipment, or where the broker is able to exercise control over the shipment because the broker owns the shipper, the shipper owns the broker, or there is common ownership of the two. The rule targets the broker who takes a fee from the carrier for moving freight the broker already controls. A broker shall not give or offer to give anything of value to any shipper, consignor or consignee, or their officers or employees, except inexpensive advertising items given for promotional purposes. A branded pen is fine. A gift card, a rebate, or a paid lunch for the shipping manager is not.
Section 371.10, duties and obligations, is a single sentence with a wide reach. Where the broker acts on behalf of a person bound by law or FMCSA regulation as to the transmittal of bills or payments, the broker must also abide by the law or regulations which apply to that person. A broker who handles billing or payment transmittal for a shipper or carrier steps into the billing rules that bind that party. The section is short, but it means a broker cannot use the broker role as a shield against payment rules that would bind the principal.
Section 371.13, accounting, binds brokers who run more than one business. Each broker who engages in any other business shall maintain accounts so that the revenues and expenses relating to the brokerage portion of its business are segregated from its other activities. Expenses that are common shall be allocated on an equitable basis. The broker must be prepared to explain the basis for the allocation. A broker who also runs trucks, a warehouse, or a repair shop cannot mix the books. The brokerage revenue plus expenses must sit in their own accounts, with shared costs split on a basis the broker can explain to an auditor.
Two more filings sit outside Part 371 but beside it in every broker compliance conversation. A broker must file a BOC-3 process agent designation, with agents in every state where the broker has offices or writes contracts. The BOC-3 Coverage Checker tests that coverage. A new broker files an OP-1 application, waits out the protest window, files the BMC-84 bond or BMC-85 trust fund plus the BOC-3, then activates. The Operating Authority Activation Timeline works out the dates. Neither filing replaces the record rule. The record rule replaces neither filing. All three belong in a broker compliance file.
What happens when a broker breaks the record rule?
A broker who fails the record rule faces three kinds of consequence: a civil penalty, a threat to the operating authority, plus a lost dispute. None of them needs a new rulemaking. All three exist under the current law.
The civil penalty comes from Part 386 Appendix B, the FMCSA penalty schedule. FMCSA said in the 2024 proposal that the existing penalties in the appendix already cover violations of the commercial regulations, including the broker record rule, with no new penalty schedule proposed as part of the rulemaking. The appendix figures are inflation-adjusted, so a figure quoted from memory is likely out of date. This tool does not hardcode a penalty figure. The FMCSA Fine Calculator works out the current inflation-adjusted penalty for a given violation. Check the figure there before quoting it anywhere.
The authority consequence is the heavier one. FMCSA may suspend or revoke a broker operating authority for willful failure to comply with a condition of registration, under 49 USC 13905(d)(2)(A)(iii). Registration as a broker carries an agreement to comply with all applicable regulations, under 49 USC 13904(a)(2). A broker who willfully keeps no records, or who destroys records inside the three year window, is failing a condition of the registration itself. FMCSA may also decline to renew a broker registration when the broker has shown it is not willing or able to comply with the regulations. A record violation is not a paperwork footnote when the authority itself is on the line.
The dispute consequence is the most common. A broker who cannot produce the record of a transaction cannot prove what the transaction was. A carrier who claims underpayment, a shipper who claims overcharge, or a claimant who disputes a deduction all start from the record. A broker with a complete record answers from the file. A broker without one answers from memory. Memory loses to a paper trail. The three year retention period exists partly for this reason: disputes surface late. The record is the evidence that settles them.
Complaints are the trigger FMCSA watches. A carrier who is refused a record can file a complaint through the National Consumer Complaint Database, attaching the written request plus the refusal. FMCSA said in the 2024 proposal that it received at least 32 complaints about broker transparency from 2018 through 2020. Broker transparency has since become a topic of intense interest in the transportation industry. A single complaint rarely moves an agency. A pattern of complaints about one broker does. It is the pattern that feeds the rulemaking record as well as the enforcement file.
The practical lesson for a broker is simple: the record rule is cheap to follow and expensive to break. The six elements are facts the broker already holds in the transport management system, the settlement sheet, plus the accounting screen. The three year clock is a calendar entry. The review right costs an email when a carrier asks. Against that, the penalty schedule, the authority risk, plus the lost dispute all run the other way. Run this checker on a sample of recent transactions, fix what it finds, then set the purge settings in the transport management system to three years or longer. That is the whole compliance program for this rule.
How do you use the Broker Record-Retention Checker?
Work through the fields in order. The tool updates with every change, so you can fix an answer and watch the verdict change.
- Pick your role: broker or carrier.
- Enter the transaction date.
- Brokers: tick each record element you keep, plus say whether the record is still kept.
- Carriers: answer the waiver, request, plus response questions.
- Read the verdict plus the per-element table.
- Fix each failed item, then run the check again.
Use the transaction documents, not memory. The bill of lading gives the date plus the bill number. The settlement sheet gives the compensation plus the payer. The accounting screen gives the freight charges collected plus the payment date. The rate confirmation plus the broker carrier agreement give the waiver clause. A checker fed from memory gives a verdict only as good as the memory behind it.
Read the figures table before the action list. It shows the transaction date, the retention expiry date, the days remaining, the elements recorded, plus the missing elements by name, so you can see which element is closest to failing even when the record passes. A record that passes with zero days left in the retention period needs no fix today, but it needs a decision about whether to keep it past the expiry date. The figures table is where that decision shows.
Questions brokers and carriers ask
How long must a broker keep transaction records?
Three years, under section 371.3(b). This tool counts the three years from the transaction date, so a transaction dated November 19, 2023 carries a retention expiry of November 19, 2026. After the period runs, the regulation no longer requires the record, but keeping it longer is allowed and often wise when a dispute surfaces late.
What six items must a broker transaction record show?
The consignor name plus address; the originating carrier name, address, plus registration number; the bill of lading or freight bill number; the brokerage compensation received plus the payer name; any non-brokerage services with their compensation plus payer; and any freight charges collected plus the date of payment to the carrier. Elements (5) and (6) apply only when the broker performed a non-brokerage service or collected freight charges on that transaction.
Can a carrier see what the broker was paid on a load?
Yes. Element (4) of section 371.3(a) requires the record to show the amount of compensation received by the broker for the brokerage service plus the name of the payer. Section 371.3(c) gives each party to the transaction the right to review the record. The practical limit is the waiver clause in the rate confirmation, not the regulation. Ask in writing, cite section 371.3(c), plus keep a copy of the request.
Can a broker make a carrier waive the right to see the records?
Under the current rule, yes in practice. FMCSA said in the 2024 proposal that a party may waive a right unless Congress makes it non-waivable. No statute does so for the review right. The proposal did not ban waiver clauses. Instead it would reframe disclosure as an affirmative broker duty, which a contract clause could not waive. That proposal is still pending OIRA review, so the waiver clause stands for now.
Is there a 48 hour deadline for a broker to hand over records?
No, not in force. The 2024 proposal would require brokers to provide transaction records within 48 hours of a request from a party. The supplemental proposal went to OIRA on August 27, 2026. It is still pending review as checked on November 19, 2026. No final rule has published. No compliance date exists. Under the current rule there is no deadline at all for a broker to answer a review request.
Does the record rule cover household goods brokers?
Household goods brokers serving individual shippers follow Subpart B of Part 371, starting at section 371.101, which sets separate rules for that trade. This tool covers property broker records under Subpart A, section 371.3. A household goods broker serving commercial or government shippers sits outside Subpart B.
Related tools
- Broker Credit Check: check a broker bond, authority, plus filings history before hauling the load.
- BOC-3 Coverage Checker: check process agent coverage in every state where the broker operates.
- DOT Record Retention Checker: retention clocks for carrier records, from driver files to logbooks.
- Broker Credit and Safety Verification Checklist: the eight checks to run before accepting a load from a broker you have not worked with before.
- Operating Authority Activation Timeline: how long new authority takes to go active, from OP-1 to activation.
- FMCSA Fine Calculator: the current inflation-adjusted penalty for a given FMCSA violation.
Sources
- 49 CFR 371.2, Definitions (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; broker, bona fide agent, brokerage service, non-brokerage service)
- 49 CFR 371.3, Records to be kept by brokers (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; six elements, three year retention, review right)
- 49 CFR 371.7, Misrepresentation (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; registered name, no holding out as a carrier)
- 49 CFR 371.9, Rebating and compensation (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; no compensation from a carrier on a controlled shipment, no gifts of value)
- 49 CFR 371.10, Duties and obligations of brokers (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; bill and payment transmittal rules)
- 49 CFR 371.13, Accounting (eCFR, read verbatim Nov 19, 2026; segregated brokerage accounts)
- Transparency in Property Broker Transactions, 89 FR 91648 (Federal Register, Nov 20, 2024; NPRM, Docket FMCSA-2023-0257, RIN 2126-AC63)
- Docket FMCSA-2023-0257 (regulations.gov; petitions, comments, plus the reopening notice at 90 FR 9702)
- OIRA EO 12866 review, RIN 2126-AC63 (reginfo.gov; supplemental proposal received August 27, 2026, still pending review as checked Nov 19, 2026)