Skip to main content

Trucking Mind

One previous employer per letter. This generator writes the request 49 CFR 391.23 requires for one previous employer. Send a separate request to each DOT-regulated employer that employed the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle within the previous three years.

Enter your company details, the previous employer details and the driver details. The letter updates as you change each field. Copy it, print it, or send it by email.

Your company (the requesting carrier)

The previous employer

The driver

Employment and dates

Drug and alcohol information

How you will send it

Ready to send

Request letter for James R. Calloway to Appalachian Bulk Carriers, Inc.

The letter requests employment verification plus accident data for November 10, 2023 to November 10, 2026. The alcohol and controlled substances history comes through the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse. Response expected by December 19, 2026.

The letter

Blue Ridge Freight Lines, LLC
1200 Depot Road
Roanoke, VA 24013
Phone: (540) 555-0148
Email: safety@blueridgefreight.example
USDOT: 4123456

November 19, 2026

Appalachian Bulk Carriers, Inc.
Attention: Marcus Hale, Safety Director
88 Terminal Way
Bristol, TN 37620

Re: Safety performance history request for James R. Calloway
Date of birth: March 14, 1985
Commercial driver license: VA T12345678
Last four of Social Security number: 6789
Dates of employment: May 1, 2023 to October 30, 2026

Dear Marcus Hale:

Blue Ridge Freight Lines, LLC is considering James R. Calloway for employment as a commercial motor vehicle driver. Under 49 CFR 391.23, we must investigate the safety performance history of each driver we employ with Department of Transportation regulated employers during the preceding three years. Please provide the information listed below for the driver named above.

1. General driver identification and employment verification information (49 CFR 391.23(d)(1)). Please confirm the dates of employment. Please confirm the type of commercial motor vehicle the driver operated. Please confirm whether the driver is eligible for rehire.

2. Accident data (49 CFR 391.23(d)(2)). For each accident involving the driver that occurred between November 10, 2023 and November 10, 2026, please provide the data elements listed in 49 CFR 390.15(b)(1): the date of the accident; the city or town, or most near, where the accident occurred and the State where the accident occurred; the driver name; the number of injuries; the number of fatalities; whether hazardous materials, other than fuel spilled from the fuel tanks of the motor vehicle involved in the accident, were released. Please include each accident as defined in 49 CFR 390.5. You may also include any additional accidents retained under 49 CFR 390.15(b)(2) or under your internal policies for retaining more detailed minor accident information.

For the alcohol and controlled substances history with your company, we will obtain the information through the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, as 49 CFR 391.23(e)(4) requires. This letter therefore requests only the information listed in items 1 and 2 above.

Please send your response within 30 days after you receive this request, as 49 CFR 391.23(g)(1) requires. If you have no safety performance history information to report for this driver, please send a response confirming that no such information exists, including the driver identification information and the dates of employment. Based on the date of this letter, we expect your response by December 19, 2026.

Please send your response to:
Dana Whitfield, Safety Manager
Blue Ridge Freight Lines, LLC
1200 Depot Road
Roanoke, VA 24013
Phone: (540) 555-0148
Email: safety@blueridgefreight.example

Please include specific contact information we can give the driver, in case the driver chooses to contact you about the correction or rebuttal of the data, as 49 CFR 391.23(g)(3) requires.

We will use this information only as part of deciding whether to hire the driver, as 49 CFR 391.23(k)(1) requires. We will protect the records from disclosure to any person not directly involved in that decision. We will not provide any alcohol or controlled substances information to our insurer.

49 CFR 391.23(l) protects a previous employer that furnishes information in accordance with this section from an action for defamation, invasion of privacy, or interference with a contract based on the furnishing of that information. The protection does not apply to a person who knowingly furnishes false information or who is not in compliance with the procedures specified for these investigations.

Thank you for your prompt attention to this request.

Sincerely,

Dana Whitfield
Safety Manager
Blue Ridge Freight Lines, LLC
Phone: (540) 555-0148
Email: safety@blueridgefreight.example

What the letter covers

CheckResultDetail
Reply contact informationIncludedThe letter tells the previous employer where to send the response, as 49 CFR 391.23(d) requires.
Employment verificationRequestedDates of employment, type of commercial motor vehicle operated, plus eligibility for rehire (49 CFR 391.23(d)(1)).
Accident dataRequestedThree-year period: Nov 10, 2023 to Nov 10, 2026. Six data elements per 49 CFR 390.15(b)(1).
Alcohol and controlled substancesClearinghouseObtained through the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, not in this letter (49 CFR 391.23(e)(4)). Run the pre-employment full query before the driver performs a safety-sensitive function.
Follow-up testing planNot neededRequested only when the driver has not completed all follow-up tests (49 CFR 391.23(e)(4)(i)).
Response deadline30 daysExpected by Dec 19, 2026. A previous employer with no information to report must still reply confirming that no information exists (49 CFR 391.23(g)(1)).
Consent copyClearinghouseThe Clearinghouse consent is given in the Clearinghouse, not in this letter.
Driver contact informationRequestedThe letter asks the previous employer for the contact information the driver needs to seek a correction or a rebuttal (49 CFR 391.23(g)(3)).
Confidentiality and use limitsStatedThe letter states that the information is used only for the hiring decision and is protected from disclosure (49 CFR 391.23(h) and (k)).
Liability protectionStatedThe letter notes the protection for a previous employer that furnishes information in accordance with this section (49 CFR 391.23(l)).
Filing reminderFile itFile a copy of the sent letter plus the reply in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the date employment begins (49 CFR 391.23(c)(1)).

The figures

FigureValueNote
Three-year lookback periodNov 10, 2023 to Nov 10, 2026Accident data, 49 CFR 391.23(d)(2)
Response dueDec 19, 202630 days after the request is received, 49 CFR 391.23(g)(1)
File deadlineDec 23, 2026Replies or good-faith documentation in the driver investigation history file, 49 CFR 391.23(c)(1)
Previous employer record retention1 yearEach request and response, 49 CFR 391.23(g)(4)
Investigation history file retentionEmployed plus 3 yearsDriver investigation history file, 49 CFR 391.53(c)
Request items in the letter2Numbered items in the generated letter
Letter length586 wordsCopy, print, or send by email

What to do

  • Mail the letter to Appalachian Bulk Carriers, Inc., 88 Terminal Way, Bristol, TN 37620.
  • Run the pre-employment full query in the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse before the driver performs a safety-sensitive function (49 CFR 391.23(e)(4)).
  • File a copy of the sent letter in the driver investigation history file today. File the reply when it arrives (49 CFR 391.23(c)(1)).
  • If no reply arrives within 30 days, document the good-faith efforts to obtain the information. Consider reporting the failure to the FMCSA under 49 CFR 386.12 (49 CFR 391.23(c)(3)).
  • Give the driver the written notice of due-process rights before any hiring decision: the right to review the information, to have errors corrected, plus to attach a rebuttal (49 CFR 391.23(i)(1)).

Notes

  • This letter covers one previous employer. Send a separate request to each DOT-regulated employer that employed the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle within the previous three years.
  • The 30-day response clock starts when the previous employer receives the request, not when you send it. Keep proof of the send date and the delivery date.
  • The driver due-process period is separate from the 30-day filing requirement (49 CFR 391.23(c)(1)).
  • Keep the driver investigation history file in a secure location with controlled access. Access is limited to those involved in the hiring decision (49 CFR 391.53(a)).
  • Do not send alcohol or controlled substances information to your insurer (49 CFR 391.23(k)(2)).

This generator applies 49 CFR 391.23, 390.15, 40.321 and 391.53 to your answers. Confirm the letter against the current regulation and your company policy before you rely on a result.

Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.

Disclaimer: This tool is provided for general information only. It is not legal advice — check the current regulation and your company policy before you rely on a result.

Quick answer: A safety performance history request is the letter a motor carrier sends to a driver previous DOT-regulated employer under 49 CFR 391.23. It asks for three things: general driver identification and employment verification, accident data for the three-year period before the employment application date, plus alcohol and controlled substances information when the driver held a safety-sensitive function. Since January 6, 2023, the drug and alcohol part for an FMCSA-regulated employer comes through the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, not through the letter. The previous employer must respond within 30 days after receiving the request. The reply, or documentation of a good-faith effort to get it, must be in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the date employment begins. This generator writes the complete letter with the correct dates, the correct citations, plus the reply address the regulation requires.

Last reviewed: · Focus keyword: safety performance history request letter

What is a safety performance history request?

A safety performance history request is the letter a motor carrier sends to a driver previous employer to learn how that driver performed in a safety-sensitive job. Section 391.23 of Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations requires the investigation. Every motor carrier must investigate the safety performance history of each driver it employs with Department of Transportation regulated employers during the preceding three years. The letter is the most common way to run that investigation, because it creates a paper trail: the request itself, the reply, plus the dates of both, all filed together.

The request is not a reference check in the ordinary sense. A reference check asks whether someone was a good employee. A safety performance history request asks for specific facts the regulation names: who the driver is, when the driver worked there, what commercial motor vehicle the driver operated, what accidents the driver was involved in, plus what the drug and alcohol testing record shows. The previous employer must answer. The carrier must file the answer. An auditor who opens the driver investigation history file expects to find the reply, or documentation of a good-faith effort to get it, within 30 days of the date employment begins.

The request covers one previous employer at a time. A driver with three DOT-regulated employers in the past three years needs three requests. Each one goes to a different company, each one carries its own employment dates, plus each one has its own 30-day reply clock. This generator writes one letter per run. Run it again for the next employer, change the employer details plus the employment dates, then send that letter too. Keep a copy of every letter you send. The copy is the start of the written record section 391.23(c)(2) requires for each previous employer contacted.

The letter matters most at the hiring decision. Section 391.23(k)(1) limits the use of the information to deciding whether to hire the driver. That is the whole purpose of the file. A carrier that hires first and investigates later has the order backwards, even though the regulation allows 30 days after employment begins to complete the file. The smart order is to send the request as soon as the application lands, read the reply before the hiring decision, plus file both the request and the reply the day they move. The Pre-Hire Investigation Deadline Tracker keeps the dates for the whole investigation in one place.

What does 49 CFR 391.23 require a carrier to investigate?

Section 391.23(a) requires two investigations for each driver a motor carrier employs, other than a driver continuously employed since before January 1, 1971. The first is an inquiry to each driver licensing authority where the driver held or holds a motor vehicle operator license or permit during the preceding three years, to obtain the motor vehicle record covering the prior three-year driving history. That inquiry must go out within 30 days of the date employment begins. A copy of each record obtained must be placed in the driver qualification file within the same 30 days.

The second investigation is the safety performance history with Department of Transportation regulated employers during the preceding three years. That is the investigation this generator serves. The carrier must investigate, at a minimum, the information listed in section 391.23(d) from all previous employers that employed the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle within the previous three years, plus the alcohol and controlled substances information listed in section 391.23(e) from all previous DOT-regulated employers that employed the driver in a safety-sensitive function requiring testing under Part 40 within the same period. The two lists overlap but they are not identical: the (d) list reaches every previous CMV employer, while the (e) list reaches every previous DOT-regulated employer where the driver held a safety-sensitive function.

The investigation may consist of personal interviews, telephone interviews, letters, or any other method the carrier deems appropriate. Section 391.23(c)(2) says so directly. A phone call counts, provided the carrier makes a written record of it: the previous employer name and address, the date the previous employer was contacted or the attempts made, plus the information received about the driver. Failures to contact a previous employer, or failures of a previous employer to provide the required information, must be documented. A letter has one advantage over a phone call: the letter itself is the record, dated and addressed, before the reply ever arrives.

Two more duties sit beside the investigation. Section 391.23(i)(1) requires the prospective employer to notify the driver, through the application form or another written document before any hiring decision, of the right to review the information provided by previous employers, the right to have errors corrected, plus the right to have a rebuttal statement attached. Section 391.23(m) requires the carrier to obtain the medical examiner certificate, verify the medical examiner was listed on the National Registry of Certified Medical Examiners as of the date of issuance, plus verify the CDLIS motor vehicle record details before allowing the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle. The medical side has its own tools: the DOT Physical Readiness Checker covers the physical standards, while the DOT Medical Card Expiry Tracker keeps the certification dates.

InvestigationSourceLookbackDeadline
Motor vehicle record from each licensing authority391.23(a)(1), (b)3 yearsWithin 30 days of employment start
Safety performance history from previous CMV employers391.23(a)(2), (c)(1), (d)3 yearsWithin 30 days of employment start
Alcohol and controlled substances history391.23(e)3 yearsBefore safety-sensitive work for FMCSA employers, through the Clearinghouse
Medical examiner certificate plus NRCME verification391.23(m)Current certificateBefore the driver operates a CMV

What information must the letter request from a previous employer?

Section 391.23(d) names the minimum. The letter must request general driver identification and employment verification information, plus the accident data described in section 390.15(b)(1). That is the floor. A letter that asks only whether the driver is eligible for rehire does not meet it. A letter that asks for the employment dates but never mentions accidents does not meet it either. The generator includes both items in every letter, with the citation beside each one, so the previous employer can see exactly what the regulation asks for.

The identification and employment verification item covers the facts that pin the driver to the record: the driver name, the date of birth, the license number, the dates of employment, the type of commercial motor vehicle operated, plus whether the driver is eligible for rehire. The more identifying detail the letter carries, the faster the previous employer finds the record. A letter with only a name forces the previous employer to guess which of several drivers with that name is meant. The generator puts the date of birth, the license state and number, plus the last four of the Social Security number in the reference block when you supply them. The last four digits are enough for identification. The letter never needs the full Social Security number. Sending the full number by mail or email creates a privacy risk the regulation does not require.

The accident data item covers the three-year period preceding the date of the employment application. Note the anchor: the application date, not the hire date and not the letter date. A driver who applied on November 10, 2026 has a lookback period running from November 10, 2023 to November 10, 2026, even if the letter goes out a week later. The generator computes the period from the application date you enter, then writes both dates into the letter in full, so the previous employer knows exactly which accidents to report. The next section lists the six data elements the letter asks for with each accident.

One requirement is easy to miss. Section 391.23(d) ends with a sentence that governs the letter itself: the investigation request must contain specific contact information on where the previous motor carrier employers should send the information requested. A letter with no reply address, no phone number and no email address fails that sentence. The generator builds a reply block into every letter: the contact name and title, the company name and address, plus the phone number and email address. If you leave the phone number and email address blank, the generator warns you that the letter gives only a mailing address for the reply. The Driver Application Completeness Checker covers the application that starts this whole process, including the 10-year employment history drivers most often miss.

What accident data does the letter ask for?

Section 391.23(d)(2) points to section 390.15(b)(1) for the accident data elements. That section requires every motor carrier to maintain an accident register for three years after the date of each accident, with at least six facts for each accident. The letter asks for those six facts for every accident involving the driver in the three-year period before the application date. The previous employer already keeps this register, so the request asks for records the employer has on file, not for new research.

The six elements are: the date of the accident; the city or town, or most near, where the accident occurred and the State where it occurred; the driver name; the number of injuries; the number of fatalities; whether hazardous materials, other than fuel spilled from the fuel tanks of the motor vehicle involved in the accident, were released. The generator lists all six in the letter, in the order the regulation lists them. A reply that gives the date and the city but omits the injury and fatality counts is incomplete on its face. The missing facts are the ones that matter most to the hiring decision.

The accidents covered are those defined in section 390.5: an occurrence involving a commercial motor vehicle operating on a highway in interstate or intrastate commerce which results in a fatality, bodily injury to a person who immediately receives medical treatment away from the scene, or one or more motor vehicles incurring disabling damage requiring transport away from the scene by a tow truck or other motor vehicle. Boarding and alighting from a stationary motor vehicle, plus loading and unloading of cargo, are excluded from the definition. The letter asks the previous employer to include each accident as defined in section 390.5, then adds that the employer may also include any additional accidents retained under section 390.15(b)(2) or under internal policies for retaining more detailed minor accident information. That second sentence matters: a carrier that keeps records of minor accidents is invited, not required, to share them. Many do.

Data elementSourceWhat it tells you
Date of the accident390.15(b)(1)(i)Whether the accident falls inside the three-year period
City or town, or most near, plus State390.15(b)(1)(ii)Where the accident happened, for matching against other records
Driver name390.15(b)(1)(iii)Confirms the accident belongs to this driver record
Number of injuries390.15(b)(1)(iv)Severity of the accident
Number of fatalities390.15(b)(1)(v)Severity of the accident
Hazardous materials released (other than fuel from fuel tanks)390.15(b)(1)(vi)Whether the accident involved a hazmat release

How does the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse change the request?

Since January 6, 2023, the drug and alcohol part of the investigation runs through the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse for FMCSA-regulated employers. Section 391.23(e)(4) says that employers subject to section 382.701(a) must use the Clearinghouse to comply with this section with respect to FMCSA-regulated employers. In practice that means the letter to a trucking company does not ask for drug and alcohol test results. The carrier runs a pre-employment full query in the Clearinghouse instead, before the driver performs a safety-sensitive function. The generator handles this split automatically: pick an FMCSA-regulated motor carrier as the previous employer. The letter states that the alcohol and controlled substances history will come through the Clearinghouse.

The letter still asks for drug and alcohol information in two situations. The first is a previous employer regulated by another DOT mode: aviation, rail, transit, pipeline, or maritime. Section 391.23(e)(4)(ii) requires the employer to request the alcohol and controlled substances information directly from those employers, because the FMCSA Clearinghouse does not hold their records. Pick another DOT mode in the generator, with the driver consent obtained. The letter gains a third numbered item with the three questions from section 391.23(e): whether the driver violated the alcohol and controlled substances prohibitions, whether the driver failed to undertake or complete a substance abuse professional rehabilitation program, plus whether the driver had further testing violations after completing a referral.

The second situation is the follow-up testing plan. Section 391.23(e)(4)(i) requires the employer to request the follow-up testing plan directly from the previous employer, in accordance with section 40.25(b)(5), when an applicant subject to follow-up testing has not successfully completed all follow-up tests. The Clearinghouse query does not deliver the plan. The generator adds a follow-up testing plan item to the letter when you answer yes to that question, numbered after the other items. If the driver completed all follow-up tests, or was never subject to follow-up testing, the item does not belong in the letter.

Two cautions belong here. First, the Clearinghouse query needs the driver consent. A refusal has the same consequence as a refusal to consent to the letter inquiry: under section 391.23(f)(2), the carrier must not permit the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle. Second, a Clearinghouse record can cost a driver the license itself: a prohibited status in the Clearinghouse leads to a commercial driver license downgrade. The Clearinghouse-II CDL Downgrade Checker explains the downgrade, while the Clearinghouse Query Tracker keeps the annual query schedule. A prohibited driver is also likely to face disqualification questions, which the CDL Disqualification Checker covers.

What consent must the driver give before you send the request?

Section 391.23(f)(1) requires the prospective employer to provide the previous employer with the driver consent meeting the requirements of section 40.321(b) for the release of the alcohol and controlled substances information. No consent, no inquiry. The generator enforces that rule: if you answer that no consent has been obtained, the drug and alcohol section is left out of the letter entirely, the verdict changes to a warning, plus the actions list tells you to obtain the written consent before you request that information.

Section 40.321(b) defines what counts as consent. The definition is strict. Specific written consent means a statement signed by the employee that he or she agrees to the release of a particular piece of information to a particular, explicitly identified, person or organization at a particular time. Blanket releases are prohibited. A form that authorizes the release of all test results to any future employer does not meet the rule. A form that authorizes the release of the alcohol and controlled substances history to one named carrier, for one named hiring decision, at one named time, does. Get the consent in writing, signed by the driver, naming your company, before you send the letter. Attach a copy to the letter when the drug and alcohol section is included. The generator adds an enclosure line to the letter when the consent is attached.

The consequence of a refusal is absolute. If the driver refuses to provide the consent, the prospective employer must not permit the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle for that motor carrier. Section 391.23(f)(1) states it without qualification. Section 391.23(f)(2) states the same rule for a refusal to consent to the Clearinghouse query. This is not a paperwork delay the carrier can work around by hiring the driver on other duties and sorting the consent out later. A driver who refuses consent cannot drive for that carrier. The generator states the consequence in the checks table and in the actions list whenever consent is missing, because it is the single most expensive fact in the whole investigation to overlook.

Consent is not needed for the rest of the letter. The employment verification and accident data items under section 391.23(d) do not require the driver consent. A carrier can send the letter with items 1 and 2 while the consent question is still open, then follow up with the drug and alcohol request once the consent is signed. That is the practical sequence when a driver is slow to sign: send the letter now, chase the consent in parallel. Do not let the driver behind the wheel until both pieces are complete.

How long does a previous employer have to respond?

Section 391.23(g)(1) gives the previous employer 30 days after the request is received to respond. The clock starts on receipt, not on the date you mail the letter. A letter mailed on November 19 and received on November 24 must be answered by December 24. The generator computes the expected response date as 30 days after the letter date, which is the earliest the clock can run out, then states the rule in the letter itself: please send your response within 30 days after you receive this request. Keep proof of the send date and the delivery date. Certified mail, an email read receipt, or a fax confirmation page all serve. Without proof of receipt, the 30-day clock is an argument, not a fact.

The reply duty applies even when there is nothing to report. If there is no safety performance history information to report for that driver, previous motor carrier employers are nonetheless required to send a response confirming the non-existence of any such data, including the driver identification information and dates of employment. That is the second sentence of section 391.23(g)(1). It is the sentence most often missed. A previous employer that ignores the request because the driver had a clean record has still violated the rule. The generator states the duty in the letter, so the previous employer knows a short reply confirming no information exists is required, not optional.

The previous employer has three more duties under section 391.23(g). It must take all precautions reasonably necessary to ensure the accuracy of the records. It must provide specific contact information in case the driver chooses to contact the previous employer regarding correction or rebuttal of the data. It must keep a record of each request and the response for one year, including the date, the party to whom it was released, plus a summary identifying what was provided. The generator asks for the contact information in the letter, because the driver due-process rights in section 391.23(i) depend on the driver being able to reach the right person at the previous employer.

Your own clock runs in parallel. Replies to the safety performance history investigation, or documentation of good-faith efforts to obtain the data, must be placed in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the date the driver employment begins. That is section 391.23(c)(1). The two 30-day clocks are different clocks: the previous employer clock starts when the request is received, while your filing clock starts when employment begins. Send the request early enough that both clocks can be met. The Pre-Hire Investigation Deadline Tracker computes both dates from the hire date.

DeadlineWho owes itClock startsSource
Respond to the requestPrevious employerWhen the request is received391.23(g)(1)
File the reply or good-faith documentationProspective employerDate employment begins391.23(c)(1)
Provide records to a driver who asks to review themProspective employerWritten request received (or when the information arrives)391.23(i)(2)
Correct the data or notify the driverPrevious employerDriver correction request received391.23(j)(2)
Forward a driver rebuttalPrevious employerRebuttal received391.23(j)(4)

What happens if a previous employer does not respond?

Start with the file. Section 391.23(c)(1) requires replies, or documentation of good-faith efforts to obtain the investigation data, in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the date employment begins. A previous employer that never replies does not excuse the carrier from the filing duty. The file must show the effort: the copy of the letter sent, the date it was sent, the delivery proof, plus a record of each follow-up attempt. Section 391.23(c)(2) requires a written record for each previous employer contacted, or good-faith efforts to do so, including the name and address, the date contacted or the attempts made, plus the information received. Failures to contact a previous employer, or failures of a previous employer to provide the required information, must be documented.

Then escalate. Section 391.23(c)(3) says prospective employers should report failures of previous employers to respond to an investigation to the FMCSA and use the complaint procedures specified at section 386.12. Keep a copy of the reports in the driver investigation history file as part of documenting a good-faith effort to obtain the required information. The word in the regulation is should, not must, but a filed complaint is the strongest evidence of good faith an auditor can ask for. It puts the non-responsive employer on the FMCSA record. The generator includes this step in the actions list for every letter, because the time to think about it is before the 30 days run out, not after.

Do not fill the gap with guesses. A carrier that cannot obtain the safety performance history must not invent it, must not treat the absence of a reply as a clean record, plus must not hire the driver on the assumption that no news is good news. The file should show what was asked, when it was asked, what came back, plus what did not. If the driver had no previous DOT-regulated employment during the preceding three years, section 391.23(c)(4) requires documentation that no investigation was possible, placed in the file within the same 30 days. That is a different situation from a silent previous employer. The file should say which one it is.

The hiring decision still belongs to the carrier. Section 391.23(k)(1) limits the use of the information to the hiring decision. A missing reply is itself information: a driver whose previous employer will not answer may be a driver worth a second look, or may simply have worked for a company that closed, merged, or lost its records. Document the facts, weigh them, plus make the decision on the record you have. The CDL Disqualification Checker can confirm whether the license record itself carries any disqualifying history while the employer reply is outstanding.

What rights does the driver have over the information?

Section 391.23(i) gives the driver three due-process rights. The prospective employer must tell the driver about them before any hiring decision. The notice goes through the application form or another written document. It must be given before the decision, not after. The three rights are: the right to review information provided by previous employers; the right to have errors in the information corrected by the previous employer, with the corrected information re-sent to the prospective employer; the right to have a rebuttal statement attached to the alleged erroneous information, if the previous employer and the driver cannot agree on the accuracy of the information.

The review right has its own deadlines. A driver who wishes to review previous employer-provided investigative information must submit a written request to the prospective employer, which may be done at any time, including when applying, or as late as 30 days after being employed or being notified of denial of employment. The prospective employer must provide the information to the applicant within five business days of receiving the written request. If the prospective employer has not yet received the requested information from the previous employer, the five-business-day deadline begins when the prospective employer receives the safety performance history information. If the driver has not arranged to pick up or receive the requested records within 30 days of the prospective employer making them available, the carrier may consider the driver to have waived the request to review the records.

The correction right runs against the previous employer, not the prospective employer. A driver wishing to request correction of erroneous information must send the request to the previous employer that provided the records. The previous employer must either correct and forward the information to the prospective motor carrier employer, or notify the driver within 15 days of receiving the request that it does not agree to correct the data. If the previous employer corrects the data and forwards it, that employer must also retain the corrected information as part of the driver safety performance history record and provide it to subsequent prospective employers when requests are received. If the previous employer corrects the data, there is no need to notify the driver.

The rebuttal right is the fallback when correction fails. A driver wishing to rebut information must send the rebuttal to the previous employer with instructions to include the rebuttal in the driver safety performance history. Within five business days of receiving a rebuttal, the previous employer must forward a copy to the prospective motor carrier employer, plus append the rebuttal to the driver information in the carrier appropriate file, to be included as part of the response for any subsequent investigating prospective employers for the duration of the three-year data retention requirement. The driver may submit a rebuttal initially without a request for correction, or subsequent to a request for correction. The Driver Records Rights and Rebuttal Letter Generator writes the correction and rebuttal letters a driver sends, while the DAC Dispute Letter Generator covers disputes with the separate DAC employment history report, which is a different record governed by different rules.

One more point protects the driver after the hire. The due-process period is separate from the 30-day filing requirement. Section 391.23(c)(1) says that any period of time required to exercise the driver due-process rights to review the information received, or to request a previous employer to correct or include a rebuttal, is separate and apart from the 30-day requirement to document the investigation. A driver who exercises these rights does not put the carrier filing deadline at risk. A carrier must not treat a correction request as a reason to delay the file.

How long must you keep the investigation file?

Section 391.53 answers that question. The safety performance histories received from previous employers for a driver who is hired must be retained for as long as the driver is employed by that motor carrier and for three years thereafter. A driver who works for a carrier for two years, then leaves, has an investigation history file that must be kept for five years from the hire date: two years of employment plus three years after. The file includes a copy of the driver written authorization for the carrier to seek alcohol and controlled substances history, plus a copy of each response received, or documentation of good-faith efforts to contact each previous employer.

The file must be maintained in a secure location with controlled access. Section 391.53(a) limits access to those who are involved in the hiring decision or who control access to the data. The carrier insurer may have access to the data, except the alcohol and controlled substances data. The data must only be used for the hiring decision. These limits mirror section 391.23(k)(2), which requires the prospective employer, its agents and insurers to take all precautions reasonably necessary to protect the records from disclosure to any person not directly involved in deciding whether to hire the driver, plus forbids providing any alcohol or controlled substances information to the prospective employer insurer. A filing cabinet anyone in the office can open does not meet the secure location standard. A locked cabinet or a password-protected folder with named access does.

The previous employer has a shorter duty. Section 391.23(g)(4) requires the previous employer to keep a record of each request and the response for one year, including the date, the party to whom it was released, plus a summary identifying what was provided. That one-year record is the previous employer side of the same transaction. The two retention periods are different because the two files serve different purposes: the previous employer record proves it answered, while the hiring carrier file proves it investigated.

The investigation history file is separate from the driver qualification file. The two have different retention rules. The driver qualification file is governed by section 391.51: the file is retained while the driver is employed plus three years after employment ends, while five specific record types may be removed three years after the date of execution. The DQ File Retention Checker computes the purge dates for each document type. Do not mix the two files. The investigation history file holds the safety performance history replies and the consent authorization. The qualification file holds the application, the motor vehicle records, the road test certificate, plus the medical certificate.

What are the most common mistakes with 391.23 requests?

The most common mistake is sending the letter too late. The investigation must be complete, or documented as a good-faith effort, within 30 days of the date employment begins. A carrier that hires on Monday and mails the request on Friday of the third week has left the previous employer almost no time to answer within the filing window. The previous employer has 30 days from receipt, which can run past the carrier filing deadline. The fix is to send the request the day the application arrives, before the hiring decision, so the reply is in hand when the decision is made. The generator dates the letter from the date you enter, so a letter prepared today carries today date, not a date reconstructed from memory later.

The second mistake is asking the previous employer for drug and alcohol test results that should come through the Clearinghouse. Since January 6, 2023, the FMCSA-regulated previous employer does not send test results in reply to a letter. The carrier queries the Clearinghouse. A letter that asks a trucking company for three years of drug test results asks for something the company is not supposed to send that way. It wastes the reply window on the wrong question. The generator routes the drug and alcohol request correctly: Clearinghouse for FMCSA-regulated employers, letter for other DOT modes, plus the follow-up testing plan by direct request when it applies.

The third mistake is a consent form that does not meet section 40.321(b). A blanket release, signed at the time of application, authorizing any future employer to obtain all test results, is prohibited. The consent must name a particular piece of information, a particular explicitly identified person or organization, plus a particular time. Carriers that reuse one generic consent form for every hire are building a file an auditor can fault in one look. Write the consent for the specific request, name your company, plus attach a copy to the letter.

The fourth mistake is a letter with no reply address. Section 391.23(d) requires the request to contain specific contact information on where the previous employers should send the information. A letterhead with a company name and no address, phone number or email address fails that sentence. The previous employer has nowhere to send the reply. The generator builds the reply block into every letter and warns you when the phone number and email address are both missing.

The fifth mistake is treating a silent previous employer as a clean record. No reply is not a clean record. It is a missing record. The file must show the effort to obtain it: the letter copy, the delivery proof, the follow-up attempts, plus, where appropriate, the FMCSA complaint under section 386.12. A file with a request and no reply and no follow-up documentation is an incomplete file. A file with a request, delivery proof, two follow-up calls, plus a complaint copy is a defensible file.

The sixth mistake is anchoring the three-year lookback on the wrong date. The accident data period runs back three years from the date of the employment application, not from the hire date and not from the letter date. A driver who applied in January and was hired in March has a lookback ending in January. The generator computes the period from the application date, then writes both dates into the letter, so the previous employer reports the right accidents.

How do you use the Safety Performance History Request Generator?

Work through the form in order. The letter updates with every change, so you can watch the request items, the dates, plus the checks change as you fill each field.

  1. Enter your company details: name, address, phone, email, USDOT number, plus the name and title of the person signing the letter.
  2. Enter the previous employer details: company name, contact name and title, address, phone and email, plus whether it is an FMCSA-regulated motor carrier or another DOT mode.
  3. Enter the driver details: full name, date of birth, license state and number, plus the last four of the Social Security number.
  4. Enter the employment dates with the previous employer, the date of the employment application, the date employment begins, plus the date of the letter.
  5. Answer the drug and alcohol questions: whether the driver held a safety-sensitive function, whether the signed consent is in hand, plus whether a follow-up testing plan is needed.
  6. Read the letter, the checks and the deadlines. Copy the letter, send it by the method you chose, then file a copy in the driver investigation history file.

Before you send the letter, run the Pre-Hire Investigation Deadline Tracker as well. The tracker covers the motor vehicle record inquiry plus the filing deadlines that sit beside this letter. A complete pre-hire file needs both.

Frequently asked questions

What is a 391.23 safety performance history request?

It is the written request a motor carrier sends to a driver previous DOT-regulated employer under 49 CFR 391.23. It asks for general driver identification and employment verification information, accident data for the three-year period before the employment application date, plus alcohol and controlled substances information when the driver held a safety-sensitive function. The previous employer must respond within 30 days after receiving the request.

How far back does a safety performance history request go?

Three years. Section 391.23(d) requires the investigation from all previous employers that employed the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle within the previous three years. The accident data covers the three-year period preceding the date of the employment application. The alcohol and controlled substances information covers the three years preceding the application date as well.

Does the letter ask for drug and alcohol test results?

Only from a previous employer regulated by a DOT mode other than FMCSA, such as aviation or rail, with the driver signed consent meeting 49 CFR 40.321(b) in hand. For an FMCSA-regulated motor carrier, the drug and alcohol history comes through the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse under 49 CFR 391.23(e)(4), not through the letter. The follow-up testing plan is requested directly from the previous employer when the driver has not completed all follow-up tests.

How long does a previous employer have to respond to a 391.23 request?

Thirty days after the request is received, under 49 CFR 391.23(g)(1). The previous employer must respond even when it has no safety performance history information to report, sending a reply confirming that no such information exists, including the driver identification information and the dates of employment. The previous employer must also keep a record of each request and response for one year.

What if a previous employer refuses to respond?

Document the good-faith efforts to obtain the information: the copy of the letter sent, the delivery proof, plus each follow-up attempt. File that documentation in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the date employment begins, under 49 CFR 391.23(c)(1). Section 391.23(c)(3) also says to report the failure to the FMCSA using the complaint procedures at 49 CFR 386.12, keeping a copy of the report in the file.

Can a driver see the information a previous employer sends?

Yes. Section 391.23(i) gives the driver the right to review the information, to have errors corrected by the previous employer, plus to attach a rebuttal statement when the previous employer and the driver cannot agree on accuracy. The driver submits a written request to the prospective employer, which must provide the information within five business days of receiving the request. The prospective employer must notify the driver of these rights before any hiring decision.

Related tools

Sources

Follow on WhatsApp Ask by Voice