Skip to main content

Trucking Mind

Three letters, three different addresses. The review request goes to the prospective employer. The correction request and the rebuttal go to the previous employer. Sending a letter to the wrong employer wastes the deadline.

Enter your details, pick the letters you need, then generate. Every letter updates as you change each field. Your inputs stay in this browser.

What do you need?

About you

The previous employer (the company that provided the record)

The prospective employer (the company that requested the record)

Dates

What is wrong with the record?

Documents enclosed with the correction request

2 letters ready: correction request and rebuttal

Correction request and rebuttal to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc.

The correction request goes to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc., which must correct the record and forward it to Lone Star Logistics LLC, or tell you within 15 days that it does not agree. The rebuttal goes to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc., which must forward a copy to Lone Star Logistics LLC and attach it to your file within five business days.

Your letters

Correction request to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc.

Jordan Miller
123 Main Street
Dallas, TX 75201
Phone: (214) 555-0148

November 19, 2026

Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc.
400 Industrial Parkway, Fort Worth, TX 76107

Re: Request for Correction of Safety Performance History Information Under 49 CFR 391.23(j)(1) and (j)(2)
Driver: Jordan Miller. Employed by Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc. from March 1, 2024 to October 15, 2026

To Whom It May Concern:

I am writing under 49 CFR 391.23(j)(1) to request correction of erroneous information in the safety performance history your company provided about me to Lone Star Logistics LLC.

The information in dispute is set out below.

What the record says:
The safety performance history states that I was involved in a preventable accident on June 12, 2026. It also states that my employment ended on September 30, 2026.

What is correct:
The accident on June 12, 2026 was not preventable. The police report found the other driver at fault. No citation was issued to me. My last day of employment was October 15, 2026, as shown on my final pay stub.

Section 391.23(j)(2) requires you either to correct the information and forward the corrected information to Lone Star Logistics LLC, or to notify me within 15 days of receiving this request that you do not agree to correct the information. Please respond by December 4, 2026, which is 15 days after the date of this letter. If this letter reaches you later, the 15-day period runs from the date you receive it.

If you correct the information, section 391.23(j)(2) also requires you to retain the corrected information as part of my safety performance history record and to provide it to subsequent prospective employers when they request it.

I am also enclosing a rebuttal statement under section 391.23(j)(3). Please include it in my safety performance history as that paragraph requires.

I have enclosed the following documents in support of this request: Final pay stub showing my last day of employment; Police report for the accident in dispute.

Thank you for your attention to this request.

Sincerely,

Jordan Miller
Enclosures: Final pay stub showing my last day of employment; Police report for the accident in dispute
cc: Lone Star Logistics LLC

Rebuttal to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc.

Jordan Miller
123 Main Street
Dallas, TX 75201
Phone: (214) 555-0148

November 19, 2026

Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc.
400 Industrial Parkway, Fort Worth, TX 76107

Re: Rebuttal Statement for Safety Performance History Under 49 CFR 391.23(j)(3)
Driver: Jordan Miller. Employed by Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc. from March 1, 2024 to October 15, 2026

To Whom It May Concern:

I am writing under 49 CFR 391.23(j)(3) to submit a rebuttal statement for inclusion in my safety performance history. Please attach this rebuttal to the information in dispute and keep it with my record.

My rebuttal statement:
I dispute the accident entry in my safety performance history. The June 12, 2026 accident was not preventable. The police report found the other driver at fault. I received no citation. Please attach this rebuttal to my record.

Section 391.23(j)(4) requires you, within five business days of receiving this rebuttal, to forward a copy to Lone Star Logistics LLC and to append the rebuttal to my information in your file, so that it is included in your response to any subsequent prospective employer for the duration of the three-year data retention requirement. Please complete both steps by November 26, 2026, which is five business days after the date of this letter. If this letter reaches you later, the five-business-day period runs from the date you receive it.

Thank you for your attention to this request.

Sincerely,

Jordan Miller
cc: Lone Star Logistics LLC

Your rights under 49 CFR 391.23

RightWhat it meansSection
Notice before any hiring decisionThe prospective employer must tell you, in the application form or another written document before any hiring decision, that it will investigate your safety performance history and what your rights are.391.23(i)(1)
Review the informationYou may review the information previous employers provided about you.391.23(i)(1)(i)
Have errors correctedYou may have errors corrected by the previous employer, which must then re-send the corrected information to the prospective employer.391.23(i)(1)(ii)
Attach a rebuttalIf you and the previous employer cannot agree on the accuracy of the information, you may have a rebuttal statement attached to it.391.23(i)(1)(iii)
Ask at any timeYou may ask to review the information at any time, including when you apply, or as late as 30 days after being employed or being notified of denial of employment.391.23(i)(2)
Records within five business daysThe prospective employer must provide the information within five business days of receiving your written request. If it has not yet received the information, the clock starts when it does.391.23(i)(2)
A correction decision within 15 daysThe previous employer must correct the information and forward it to the prospective employer, or notify you within 15 days that it does not agree to correct it.391.23(j)(2)
Your rebuttal rides with the recordWithin five business days of receiving your rebuttal, the previous employer must forward a copy to the prospective employer and append it to your file, so later employers see it for the three-year retention period.391.23(j)(4)
Rebuttal first, or after a correction requestYou may submit a rebuttal on its own, without asking for a correction first, or after a correction request.391.23(j)(5)
Report a failure to FMCSAYou may report a previous employer that fails to correct information or include your rebuttal to FMCSA under the complaint procedures at section 386.12.391.23(j)(6)
Hiring decision onlyThe prospective employer may use the information only as part of deciding whether to hire you.391.23(k)(1)
ConfidentialityThe prospective employer must protect the records from disclosure to anyone not directly involved in the hiring decision. It may never give alcohol or controlled substances information to its insurer.391.23(k)(2)

Checks

CheckResultDetail
Your identificationPassYour name, address and phone number are on the letter.
Previous employerPassThe letters are addressed to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc..
Prospective employerPassThe letters name Lone Star Logistics LLC as the prospective employer.
Disputed itemsPassThe letter names the items in dispute: Employment dates; Accident record.
Record text and corrected factsPassThe correction letter quotes what the record says and states what is correct.
Rebuttal statementPassYour rebuttal statement is in the rebuttal letter.
Review windowInfoNo review letter is selected, so the 30-day window does not apply.
Drug and alcohol routingInfoNo drug and alcohol dispute is selected.
EnclosuresPass2 supporting documents are listed as enclosures: Final pay stub showing my last day of employment; Police report for the accident in dispute.

Deadlines

DeadlineDateNote
Letters generated2Letter set: correction request and rebuttal.
Correction decision dueDec 4, 202615 days after the previous employer receives your correction request (391.23(j)(2)). Counted from the letter date.
FMCSA complaint window closesMar 4, 202790 days after the correction deadline passes, if the previous employer fails to correct the information or include your rebuttal (391.23(j)(6), 386.12(a)(1)).
Rebuttal forwarded and attached byNov 26, 2026Five business days after the previous employer receives your rebuttal (391.23(j)(4)). Counted from the letter date.

What to do

  • Send the correction request to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc..
  • Send the rebuttal to Bluebonnet Freight Lines, Inc. with instructions to include it in your safety performance history.
  • Send each letter by a method that proves delivery, such as certified mail with return receipt requested. Keep a copy of every letter plus the proof of delivery.
  • If the previous employer misses the correction deadline of Dec 4, 2026, report the failure to FMCSA under section 386.12 within 90 days.
  • Check that the rebuttal reaches Lone Star Logistics LLC by Nov 26, 2026.
  • Keep the corrected record. Ask the previous employer to confirm the correction in writing.

Notes

  • Business days are Monday through Friday. A federal holiday inside a five-business-day window moves the deadline by one day. This tool counts Monday through Friday only and does not track holidays.
  • The time you spend exercising your due-process rights is separate from the carrier 30-day investigation deadline (391.23(c)(1)). Your dispute does not extend the carrier deadline. The carrier deadline does not cut your dispute short.
  • The defamation shield in section 391.23(l) does not protect a previous employer that knowingly furnishes false information, or one that does not follow the procedures in the section.
  • The prospective employer may use the information only to decide whether to hire you. It must protect the information from disclosure to anyone not directly involved in that decision (391.23(k)).
  • This tool never asks for your Social Security number. Add only the identifiers the employer needs to find your file, such as your dates of employment.

This generator applies 49 CFR 391.23(i) to (k), 390.15(b)(1) and 386.12 to your answers. Confirm the letters against the current regulation before you send them.

Your inputs stay in this browser. Nothing is sent to our servers. There is no account to create.

Disclaimer: This tool is provided for general information only. It is not legal advice — check the current regulation before you rely on a letter.

Quick answer: Under 49 CFR 391.23, a driver with DOT-regulated employment in the preceding three years has the right to review the safety performance history previous employers provided, to have errors corrected by the previous employer, plus the right to have a rebuttal statement attached to any information the driver and the previous employer cannot agree on. The review request goes to the prospective employer in writing, as late as 30 days after being employed or being notified of denial of employment. The prospective employer must provide the records within five business days. The correction request and the rebuttal go to the previous employer: the previous employer must correct the record and forward it, or tell the driver within 15 days that it does not agree. It must forward a rebuttal and attach it to the file within five business days. This generator writes all three letters and computes every deadline.

Last reviewed: · Focus keyword: dispute driver safety record

What is a safety performance history?

A safety performance history is the record a prospective employer collects about a driver from previous employers before making a hiring decision. Section 391.23(a)(2) requires every motor carrier to investigate the safety performance history of each driver it employs, covering DOT-regulated employment during the preceding three years. The investigation runs alongside the motor vehicle record inquiry in section 391.23(a)(1). Together they form the pre-hire investigation. The Pre-Hire Investigation Deadline Tracker covers the carrier side of those deadlines.

Section 391.23(d) sets the minimum the prospective employer must investigate from every previous employer that employed the driver to operate a commercial motor vehicle within the previous three years. The first item is general driver identification and employment verification information: who the driver is, when the driver worked there, plus what the driver did. The second item is accident data, using the data elements in section 390.15(b)(1) for accidents in the three-year period before the application date. Those elements are the date of the accident, the city or town and the State where it happened, the driver name, the number of injuries, the number of fatalities, plus whether hazardous materials other than fuel spilled from the fuel tanks were released.

Section 391.23(e) adds a second layer for previous DOT-regulated employers that employed the driver in a safety-sensitive function requiring alcohol and controlled substance testing under Part 40. The prospective employer must ask whether the driver violated the alcohol and controlled substances prohibitions in Part 382 subpart B or Part 40 within the previous three years, whether the driver failed to undertake or complete a rehabilitation program prescribed by a substance abuse professional. For a driver who completed a referral and stayed with the referring employer, it must ask about later testing violations, such as an alcohol test of 0.04 or higher, a verified positive drug test, or a refusal to be tested.

Since January 6, 2023, one part of that picture has moved. Section 391.23(e)(4) requires employers subject to section 382.701(a) to use the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse to comply with the drug and alcohol part of the investigation for FMCSA-regulated employers. The Clearinghouse, not the previous employer, is now the source of that information. Two exceptions still run through the previous employer directly: the follow-up testing plan for a driver who has not completed all follow-up tests. The second covers drug and alcohol information from employers regulated by a DOT mode other than FMCSA. The distinction matters for disputes, because a Clearinghouse record and a previous-employer record are challenged through different routes.

The previous employer has duties of its own. Section 391.23(g)(1) requires a response to each request within 30 days after the request is received. If there is no safety performance history information to report, the previous employer must still send a response confirming that no such data exists, including the driver identification information and the dates of employment. Section 391.23(g)(2) requires the previous employer to take all precautions reasonably necessary to ensure the accuracy of the records. Section 391.23(g)(3) requires the previous employer to provide specific contact information in case a driver chooses to contact the previous employer about correction or rebuttal of the data. That contact information is the address the correction and rebuttal letters go to.

What rights does 49 CFR 391.23 give a driver?

Section 391.23(i)(1) gives a driver three rights over the investigative information. It also puts a notice duty on the prospective employer to match. The prospective employer must expressly notify drivers with DOT-regulated employment during the preceding three years, via the application form or another written document before any hiring decision, that the driver has the following rights regarding the information that will be provided under paragraphs (d) and (e). The notice comes first, before the decision, so the driver knows the rights exist while they still matter.

The first right is the right to review information provided by previous employers. The second right is the right to have errors in the information corrected by the previous employer, with that employer re-sending the corrected information to the prospective employer. The third right is the right to have a rebuttal statement attached to the alleged erroneous information, if the previous employer and the driver cannot agree on the accuracy of the information. The three rights form a sequence: see the record, fix the record, then, where agreement is impossible, put your side of the story on the record.

The rights summary in the tool lists every right with its citation, including the ones that sit outside paragraph (i). Section 391.23(j)(5) lets a driver submit a rebuttal initially without a request for correction, or after one. Section 391.23(j)(6) lets a driver report a previous employer failure to FMCSA. Section 391.23(k)(1) limits the prospective employer to using the information only as part of deciding whether to hire the driver. Section 391.23(k)(2) requires the prospective employer to protect the records from disclosure to anyone not directly involved in the hiring decision. It forbids giving alcohol or controlled substances information to its insurer. Section 391.23(l)(2) removes the defamation shield from anyone who knowingly furnishes false information.

One more protection sits in paragraph (c). Section 391.23(c)(1) states that any period of time required to exercise the driver due-process rights to review the information received, plus the time to request a previous employer to correct or include a rebuttal, is separate and apart from the carrier 30-day requirement to document the investigation. The carrier must still place the replies, or documentation of its good-faith efforts, in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the hire date. The driver dispute does not extend that deadline. The carrier deadline does not cut the driver dispute short. The two clocks run independently.

The notice duty is worth checking in practice. If a carrier never told you about these rights before making a hiring decision, that is a failure of section 391.23(i)(1). The rights still exist. A driver who learns of them later may still exercise them. The review request window in paragraph (i)(2) runs from the hire date or the denial notice, not from the date the notice was given, so a late discovery still leaves the correction and rebuttal routes open. The Driver Application Completeness Checker covers the application form where the notice usually appears.

How do you ask to review your safety performance history?

The review request is a written request to the prospective employer, not to the previous employer. Section 391.23(i)(2) states that drivers who have previous DOT-regulated employment history in the preceding three years who wish to review previous employer-provided investigative information, must submit a written request to the prospective employer. The request may be made at any time, including when applying, or as late as 30 days after being employed or being notified of denial of employment. A letter, an email, or any other written form counts. A phone call does not, because the regulation requires a written request. A written request leaves proof.

The prospective employer must provide the information to the applicant within five business days of receiving the written request. There is one qualification. If the prospective employer has not yet received the requested information from the previous employer, then the five-business-day deadline begins when the prospective employer receives the requested safety performance history information. The clock does not run against information the prospective employer does not yet hold. The generator computes the five-business-day date from the letter date and states the rule in the letter, so the employer cannot claim confusion about the deadline.

The pickup rule is the part drivers miss most often. Section 391.23(i)(2) states that if the driver has not arranged to pick up or receive the requested records within thirty days of the prospective employer making them available, the prospective motor carrier may consider the driver to have waived the request to review the records. The waiver is not automatic. The regulation says the carrier may consider the request waived. A driver who arranges pickup promptly never tests the question. The generator computes the pickup deadline from the records-due date and lists it as an action item, so it is not forgotten.

The review letter the generator writes does three things. It identifies the driver and the previous employment. It cites section 391.23(i)(2) and states the five-business-day duty. It asks the prospective employer to say when the records are available and how the driver may pick them up or receive them. If dispute types are selected, the letter also names the items in dispute, which signals to the employer that a correction request or a rebuttal may follow. The letter does not argue the merits. Argument belongs in the correction request and the rebuttal, which go to the previous employer.

Timing the review request is a matter of judgment. Asking when applying gets the records early, while the hiring decision is still open. Asking after a denial still works inside the 30-day window. The records may explain the denial. Asking after being hired works the same way. There is no advantage in waiting. The record only becomes harder to correct as time passes, because the previous employer keeps its request and response records for only one year under section 391.23(g)(4). Memories fade faster than files.

How do you ask a previous employer to correct an error?

The correction request goes to the previous employer that provided the records, not to the prospective employer. Section 391.23(j)(1) states that drivers wishing to request correction of erroneous information in records received pursuant to paragraph (i) must send the request for the correction to the previous employer that provided the records to the prospective employer. The prospective employer cannot correct a record it did not create. It can only pass the corrected information on once the previous employer sends it.

Section 391.23(j)(2) gives the previous employer two options and one deadline. The previous employer must either correct and forward the information to the prospective motor carrier employer, or notify the driver within 15 days of receiving a driver request to correct the data that it does not agree to correct the data. The 15 days are calendar days, not business days. The regulation says 15 days, where the review and rebuttal deadlines say five business days. The generator counts the 15 days as calendar days and the five-business-day deadlines as Monday through Friday.

Two details in paragraph (j)(2) matter for the letter. First, if the previous employer corrects and forwards the data as requested, that employer must also retain the corrected information as part of the driver safety performance history record and provide it to subsequent prospective employers when requests for this information are received. The correction is not a one-off fix for a single application. It becomes the record. Second, if the previous employer corrects the data and forwards it to the prospective motor carrier employer, there is no need to notify the driver. A driver who hears nothing after 15 days should check with the prospective employer, because silence may mean the correction went through.

The correction letter the generator writes quotes what the record says, states what is correct, then cites section 391.23(j)(2) with the response date. Quoting the record exactly matters. A vague complaint about an unfair record gives the previous employer nothing to check. A letter that says the record lists a preventable accident on June 12, 2026, plus the fact that the police report found the other driver at fault with no citation issued, gives the previous employer a specific claim to verify against its own file. Enclosures strengthen the request. A final pay stub proves an end date. A police report proves fault. Dispatch records prove where the driver was. The generator lists the enclosures in the letter and on the enclosure line.

The correction route covers the (d) information and the (e) information the previous employer itself provided. It does not cover a Clearinghouse record. Since January 6, 2023, FMCSA-regulated employers obtain drug and alcohol violation information from the Clearinghouse under section 391.23(e)(4), so a previous employer cannot correct a record it does not hold. A driver disputing a Clearinghouse entry uses FMCSA DataQs. The DataQs Challenge Helper covers that route. The Clearinghouse Downgrade Checker covers what a Clearinghouse violation does to a CDL. The correction letter still covers drug and alcohol information the previous employer itself provided, such as a follow-up testing plan requested under section 40.25(b)(5), plus information from employers regulated by a DOT mode other than FMCSA.

What is a rebuttal and when should you use one?

A rebuttal is the statement of disagreement a driver attaches to the disputed information in the safety performance history. Section 391.23(i)(1)(iii) gives the driver the right to have a rebuttal statement attached to the alleged erroneous information, if the previous employer and the driver cannot agree on the accuracy of the information. The rebuttal does not change the record. It travels with the record, so every prospective employer that requests the history sees both versions.

Section 391.23(j)(3) states that drivers wishing to rebut information in records received pursuant to paragraph (i) must send the rebuttal to the previous employer with instructions to include the rebuttal in that driver safety performance history. Section 391.23(j)(4) then puts two duties on the previous employer, both inside five business days of receiving the rebuttal: forward a copy of the rebuttal to the prospective motor carrier employer, plus append the rebuttal to the information about the driver in the carrier file, to be included as part of the response for any subsequent investigating prospective employers for the duration of the three-year data retention requirement. The rebuttal rides with the record for three years. It is not a note that disappears after one application.

Section 391.23(j)(5) gives the driver a choice of order. The driver may submit a rebuttal initially without a request for correction, or subsequent to a request for correction. A driver who expects the previous employer to refuse a correction may send the rebuttal first, so the record carries the driver side from the start. A driver who thinks the previous employer will correct the error may ask for the correction first and send the rebuttal only if the correction is refused. The generator offers both orders. The default generates the correction request and the rebuttal together, which covers both outcomes in one mailing.

A good rebuttal is short, factual and specific. It states what the driver disputes, states the facts as the driver sees them, plus names the evidence. It does not insult the previous employer, speculate about motives, or make claims the driver cannot support. The rebuttal will be read by hiring managers at companies the driver has never met. A calm, factual rebuttal helps the driver. An angry one hurts. The generator places the rebuttal statement verbatim in the letter, under its own heading, so the driver controls the exact words.

The rebuttal is also the right tool when the dispute is a matter of judgment rather than fact. An accident listed as preventable is a judgment call. The previous employer may stand by it even when the police report found the other driver at fault. A correction request asks the employer to change its judgment. A rebuttal accepts the disagreement and puts the driver facts on the record beside it. Hiring managers read both. A rebuttal that cites the police report and the absence of a citation gives the hiring manager a reason to discount the preventable label.

What are the deadlines in section 391.23?

Section 391.23 sets six deadlines that matter to a driver disputing a record. The generator computes all six from the dates entered. The table below states each one with its citation.

DeadlinePeriodSection
Request review of the records30 days after being employed or notified of denial of employment391.23(i)(2)
Prospective employer provides the records5 business days after receiving the written request391.23(i)(2)
Pick up or receive the records30 days after the prospective employer makes them available391.23(i)(2)
Previous employer corrects or refuses15 days after receiving the correction request391.23(j)(2)
Previous employer forwards and attaches the rebuttal5 business days after receiving the rebuttal391.23(j)(4)
Report a failure to FMCSA90 days after the failure391.23(j)(6), 386.12(a)(1)

The two five-business-day deadlines count Monday through Friday. The generator counts them that way and does not track federal holidays. A federal holiday inside a five-business-day window moves the deadline by one day, so a driver who counts by hand should check the calendar. The 15-day correction deadline and the two 30-day deadlines count calendar days. The regulation says 15 days and 30 days, not business days. The generator counts them as calendar days.

Every deadline in the table runs from receipt, not from mailing. The five-business-day period for the records runs from the day the prospective employer receives the written request. The 15-day correction period runs from the day the previous employer receives the correction request. The five-business-day rebuttal period runs from the day the previous employer receives the rebuttal. The generator computes each date from the letter date and states the receipt rule in the letter, so the employer knows the clock. A driver who sends a letter by certified mail with return receipt requested knows the receipt date from the green card. That date lets the driver hold the employer to the deadline.

The review request deadline deserves a second look. The 30 days run from being employed or being notified of denial of employment. A driver who is still waiting for a decision has no deadline yet, because the request may be made at any time, including when applying. A driver who was hired on November 10 has until December 10 to ask. A driver who was denied on November 10 has the same date. The generator flags the window as open or passed. The review letter goes out either way, because a late request costs nothing and may still be honored.

The carrier side has its own 30-day clock. The two clocks must not be confused. Section 391.23(c)(1) requires the prospective employer to place the investigation replies, or documentation of good-faith efforts, in the driver investigation history file within 30 days of the hire date. The previous employer must respond to the investigation request within 30 days under section 391.23(g)(1). Neither deadline belongs to the driver. The driver deadlines are the six in the table above.

What if the previous employer ignores you?

A previous employer that ignores a correction request or a rebuttal has two problems. The first is the deadline. Section 391.23(j)(2) requires a correction decision within 15 days. Section 391.23(j)(4) requires the rebuttal to be forwarded and attached within five business days. A missed deadline is a failure the regulation names. The second problem is the record. Section 391.23(g)(2) requires the previous employer to take all precautions reasonably necessary to ensure the accuracy of the records. An employer that will not even look at a documented error is not taking those precautions.

Section 391.23(j)(6) gives the driver the next step. The driver may report failures of previous employers to correct information or include a rebuttal from the driver as part of the safety performance information, to the FMCSA following procedures specified at section 386.12. Section 386.12(a)(1) sets the mechanics: a written complaint to FMCSA, filed no later than 90 days after the event, with the National Consumer Complaint Database or any FMCSA Division Administrator. The complaint must be signed and must contain the filer name, address and telephone number, the name and address of the alleged violator plus the specific provisions of the regulations the complainant believes were violated, plus a concise but complete statement of the facts relied upon, including the date of each alleged violation.

The Division Administrator decides what happens next. Section 386.12(a)(2) states that the Division Administrator shall determine whether the complaint is non-frivolous and meets the requirements. If it does, the Division Administrator investigates the complaint and notifies the complainant of the findings. If it does not, the Division Administrator dismisses the complaint and notifies the complainant in writing of the reasons. Section 386.12(a)(3) protects the complainant identity: the Division Administrator shall not disclose the identity of complainants unless it is determined that such disclosure is necessary to prosecute a violation. The Administrator must then take every practical means to ensure the complainant is not subject to coercion, harassment, intimidation, disciplinary action, discrimination, or financial loss.

The prospective employer has a reporting duty too. Section 391.23(c)(3) states that prospective employers should report failures of previous employers to respond to an investigation to the FMCSA and use the complaint procedures specified at section 386.12. They must keep a copy of the reports in the driver investigation history file as part of documenting a good-faith effort. A driver who tells the prospective employer that the previous employer has gone silent gives the prospective employer a reason to file its own report. Two complaints about the same employer carry more weight than one.

Before filing a complaint, the driver should gather the paper trail: the correction request, the proof of delivery, the 15-day deadline date, plus any reply or lack of one. The complaint needs the date of each alleged violation. The violation date for a missed correction deadline is the day after the 15 days expired. The generator computes the complaint window from the correction deadline, so the driver knows the last day to file. A complaint filed on day 91 is late. The 90 days run from the event, not from the day the driver noticed.

What can a prospective employer do with your record?

Less than most drivers assume. Section 391.23(k)(1) states that the prospective motor carrier employer must use the information described in paragraphs (d) and (e) only as part of deciding whether to hire the driver. The information may not be used for any other purpose. It may not be shared with other carriers. It may not be used to blackball a driver. It may not be sold. The hiring decision is the only permitted use.

Section 391.23(k)(2) adds a confidentiality duty. The prospective motor carrier employer, its agents and insurers must take all precautions reasonably necessary to protect the records from disclosure to any person not directly involved in deciding whether to hire the driver. The prospective motor carrier employer may not provide any alcohol or controlled substances information to the prospective motor carrier employer insurer. The drug and alcohol information is walled off even from the carrier own insurer. The previous employer side has a matching duty in section 391.23(h): the previous employer and its agents and insurers must protect the records from disclosure to anyone not directly involved in forwarding them. They may not provide alcohol or controlled substances information to the previous employer insurer either.

Section 391.23(l) gives both sides a shield against lawsuits, with a hole in it. Paragraph (l)(1) states that no action or proceeding for defamation, invasion of privacy, or interference with a contract that is based on the furnishing or use of information in accordance with this section may be brought against the investigating carrier, the person who provided the information, or their agents or insurers. Paragraph (l)(2) states that the protections do not apply to persons who knowingly furnish false information, or who are not in compliance with the procedures specified for these investigations. A previous employer that knowingly sends a false accident report has no shield. A carrier that ignores the correction procedure has no shield either.

The record does not live forever. Section 391.23(j)(4)(ii) ties the rebuttal to the three-year data retention requirement. Section 391.53(c) requires the driver investigation history file to be kept while the driver is employed and for three years after employment ends. The DQ File Retention Checker covers the retention rules for the whole driver qualification file. A rebuttal attached to a record follows it for the full three years, which is why a short, factual rebuttal is worth writing well.

The hiring-decision limit also protects a driver who was denied a job. A carrier that requested a safety performance history and then decided not to hire the driver may not pass the record to another carrier, or use it to warn other carriers about the driver. If a driver suspects the record was shared, the confidentiality duties in paragraphs (h) and (k)(2) are the provisions to cite in a complaint to FMCSA under section 386.12, alongside the specific facts showing the disclosure.

How is a safety performance history different from a DAC report and a Clearinghouse record?

Three different records follow a truck driver. Each has its own dispute route. Confusing them wastes weeks, because a letter sent to the wrong record holder achieves nothing. The safety performance history is the record previous employers provide to a prospective employer under section 391.23(d) and (e). It covers the preceding three years of DOT-regulated employment. It is disputed through the previous employer under section 391.23(j), with the letters this generator writes.

The DAC report is a private employment history report kept by HireRight, formerly USIS. Carriers report employment history, accident information and eligibility for rehire to HireRight. Other carriers buy the report when hiring. The DAC report is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which gives the driver a different set of rights: a free copy of the report, a dispute investigated within 30 days, plus a corrected report sent to anyone who received the wrong version in the past two years. The dispute goes to HireRight, not to the previous employer, although HireRight forwards the dispute to the carrier that furnished the information. The DAC Dispute Letter Generator writes that letter. A driver with a wrong DAC entry and a wrong safety performance history entry needs two disputes, because the two records are separate.

The Clearinghouse record is the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse entry for a drug or alcohol violation: a positive test, a refusal, an alcohol test of 0.04 or higher, or actual knowledge of a violation. The Clearinghouse is a federal database. The record is disputed through FMCSA DataQs, the same system used to challenge inspection and crash data. A Clearinghouse violation also carries a CDL downgrade, which the Clearinghouse Downgrade Checker explains, plus a return-to-duty process under Part 40 subpart O. The DataQs Challenge Helper covers the DataQs route. A section 391.23(j) letter to a previous employer cannot fix a Clearinghouse entry, because the previous employer does not hold that record.

A driver who was denied a job should check all three records. The denial letter may say which record caused the decision, but it often does not. The review request under section 391.23(i)(2) shows the safety performance history. A free DAC report request shows the DAC record. A Clearinghouse query shows the Clearinghouse record. Each dispute then follows its own route, with its own deadlines. The safety performance history dispute is the only one that runs through the previous employer directly. It is the only one with the 15-day correction clock and the five-business-day rebuttal clock.

One record the safety performance history is not: the motor vehicle record. The MVR comes from the State driver licensing agency, not from a previous employer. It is disputed with the State, not under section 391.23. A ticket or a conviction that appears wrongly on an MVR is a State record problem. A CDL disqualification is a separate matter again, covered by the CDL Disqualification Checker. The safety performance history covers employment and accidents as reported by previous employers. The MVR covers convictions and license actions as recorded by the State.

How do you use the Driver Records Rights and Rebuttal Letter Generator?

Start with the letters you need, then fill in the details. The generator updates with every change, so you can watch the letters take shape as you type.

  1. Pick the letters: review request, correction request, rebuttal, correction request and rebuttal, or all three.
  2. Enter your details and the two employers: the previous employer that provided the record, plus the prospective employer that requested it.
  3. Enter the dates: the date on the letter, plus the date you were hired or notified of denial of employment, which sets the 30-day review window.
  4. Pick what is wrong with the record, then write what the record says and what is correct, plus your rebuttal statement in your own words.
  5. Tick the documents you will enclose, then read the letters, the rights summary and the deadline table.
  6. Copy or print the letters, send each one to the right employer by a method that proves delivery. Calendar the deadlines.

Before you send the correction request, run the Safety Performance History Request Generator to see the letter from the carrier side. It shows what a carrier asks a previous employer for, which helps you check whether the record you received matches what the carrier requested.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a previous employer have to correct my safety performance history?

Section 391.23(j)(2) gives the previous employer 15 days after receiving your correction request. Within that time it must either correct the information and forward the corrected information to the prospective employer, or notify you that it does not agree to correct the data. The 15 days are calendar days, not business days. If it corrects and forwards the information, it must also keep the corrected information in your record and send it to later prospective employers. It need not notify you.

Can I submit a rebuttal without asking for a correction first?

Yes. Section 391.23(j)(5) states that the driver may submit a rebuttal initially without a request for correction, or subsequent to a request for correction. The rebuttal goes to the previous employer with instructions to include it in your safety performance history. Within five business days the previous employer must forward a copy to the prospective employer and append the rebuttal to your file, so it reaches later employers for the three-year retention period.

How late can I ask to review my safety performance history?

Section 391.23(i)(2) lets you ask at any time, including when applying, or as late as 30 days after being employed or being notified of denial of employment. The request must be in writing to the prospective employer. The prospective employer must provide the information within five business days of receiving the request, or five business days after it receives the information from the previous employer if it has not yet received it. Pick up the records within 30 days of the employer making them available, or it may treat the request as waived.

What if the previous employer refuses to correct an error?

Send a rebuttal under section 391.23(j)(3), which the previous employer must forward to the prospective employer and attach to your file within five business days. You may also report the failure to FMCSA under section 391.23(j)(6), following the complaint procedures at section 386.12: a written complaint filed no later than 90 days after the event with the National Consumer Complaint Database or a FMCSA Division Administrator. The defamation shield in section 391.23(l) does not protect an employer that knowingly furnishes false information.

Can I dispute a drug or alcohol violation with a 391.23 letter?

It depends on where the record lives. Since January 6, 2023, FMCSA-regulated employers obtain drug and alcohol violation information from the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse under section 391.23(e)(4), so a Clearinghouse record is disputed through FMCSA DataQs, not through a letter to the previous employer. The correction letter still covers drug and alcohol information the previous employer itself provided, such as a follow-up testing plan or information from an employer regulated by a DOT mode other than FMCSA.

Is a safety performance history the same as a DAC report?

No. A safety performance history is the record previous employers provide to a prospective employer under section 391.23, covering the preceding three years of DOT-regulated employment. It is disputed through the previous employer. A DAC report is a private employment history report kept by HireRight and disputed under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. A Clearinghouse record is a federal drug and alcohol violation record disputed through FMCSA DataQs. Each record needs its own dispute.

Related tools

Sources

Follow on WhatsApp Ask by Voice